Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Design-Based School Improvement in Chilean Schools and Municipal Administrations

Fri, April 17, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Virtual Room

Abstract

The RPP in Chile has been working with two public local administrative units (one with 10 schools and one with 60 schools) and two pilot schools, one in each unit, for the last three years. The research methodology is action research (Coghlan & Brannick, 2007) through which researchers collect data on change processes in which they, themselves, are involved.

In the Chilean case, the design-based improvement logic is introduced through two workshops lasting two days each. Leaders from the schools and local administrative units participate in these training sessions. Subsequently, the local units, whose role it is to support schools and the pilot schools are accompanied by RPP staff who visit the units about once a month to initiate and deepen the insights from the workshops.

Data from the meetings with the schools and the local units, called Departamento de Administración de Educación Municipal (DAEM), reveal the following pattern. The logic of design-based school improvement is picked up with enthusiasm at both the school and municipal levels. It speaks to, and makes visible the internal voice of school practitioners and their practice, a dimension of reality that an improvement dynamic strongly induced from the ‘outside’ usually overlooks. The logic wedges itself between the overbearing central state and the stirring of oppositional forces coming from the grassroots in which educators claim voice and attention to their challenges and needs. But the practical implementation poses major challenges. By US-American or German standards, the system is organized along strict hierarchical lines. A social distance exists between the principal and the leadership team in the school, on one hand, and the ordinary teachers in the classrooms. Likewise, a similar distance exists between district support teams and the school. In terms of school improvement, both district support teams and principals are primarily concerned about implementing the various policy initiatives or managerial mandates handed down from the national government. Teachers perceive school improvement efforts as disconnected from the obstacles that they daily face when provide the education service. As a result, the teachers’ voice and the problems directly emanating from the interaction between teachers and students are crowded out (Frey & Jegen, 2001). This crowding-out diminishes the motivation with which teachers embrace school improvement efforts.

So the first challenge, as a design-based logic enters schools, is the silence of the teachers’ voice in ‘official’ school improvement undertakings. And representatives of the RPP have to find ways to activate this voice and to attenuate the voice of principals in school meetings and DAEM demands in meetings with school leaders, in order to uncover an authentic representation of teachers’ passions and urgencies. Design-based school improvement is a technology or a model that structures educators’ conversations about their own authentic problems of practice that urgently call for solutions. In the Chilean cases, this technology cannot take off without a flattening of hierarchies and the empowerment of the teacher voice.

Author