Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Using Performance Assessments to Simulate and Provide Feedback for Key Teaching Skills

Fri, April 17, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Virtual Room

Abstract

Objective and Framework
This paper explores the use of assessments of simulated teaching performance as a tool for TCs to practice and receive feedback on critical teaching skills.

Grossman et al. (2009) identified three concepts that guide the use of simulation in professional education: representations, approximations, and decompositions. Moss (2011) expanded on these ideas arguing that conceptions of quality are also needed to support judgements about “whether some instance of practice is more or less mature, sophisticated, or successful, and to offer direction for improvement or development” (p. 2879). Short, standardized simulations that direct TCs to deliver a teaching performance (e.g., modeling how to identify evidence to support an interpretation of a text passage) provide opportunities to focus on and rehearse specified teaching skills and receive feedback. Scored simulations also create the opportunity for TCs to consider their performance against clearly specified standards of quality.

Methods
Progress has been made in assessing the content knowledge used in the tasks that make up the work of teaching—e.g., evaluating student work, representing content, eliciting student thinking, explaining and modeling concepts, and more (for example, Ball, Thames & Phelps, 2008; Gitomer, et al, 2014; Phelps, et al, 2019). We expand on this work to simulate the enactment of content knowledge in teaching. TCs are situated in an instance of teaching (such as evaluating student work for potential confusion) and then asked to give a teaching response that is delivered as if to actual students (model for the student how to do the work). Because each simulation is very short, TCs have time to attempt multiple “do-overs” of the same simulated performance after receiving feedback, they can work across many different /representations of teaching, and teacher educators can feasibly work with performances for larger group of students.

Data Sources
Twenty simulation performance tasks in elementary reading language arts and mathematics were administered to 59 preservice teachers. Results from this study include task performances, timing data, and survey results on participant opinions.

Results
Initial analyses confirm that the simulated performances can be completed in a short amount of time: average times for TCs to deliver the performance component range from 1.25 to 2.13 minutes and average time including preparation range from 2.4 to 4.5 minutes. TCs overwhelmingly agreed that the simulated performances are important for teaching (98%), authentic (95%), important to include in licensure (95%), and a focus of their teacher preparation (89%). In August 2019, the 1,180 simulated performances will be triple scored by trained raters and results on the measurement characteristics will be shared in this session.

Significance
Teacher educators have limited options of simulations to use in methods classes that allow TCs to practice teaching, and even fewer options that provide explicit standards of quality to guide feedback. Many simulations require substantial time both to both complete and provide feedback. This session considers potential for short simulated performances that can be “scored” to facilitate providing accurate, high-quality feedback on content teaching skills.

Author