Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This investigation contributes to research delineating how learning environments assist youth in asserting cultural and political self-determination. In traditions of critical pedagogy (Freire 1970, Gee 2007, Gutierrez et al. 1999), a central purpose of education is to encourage multivoicedness (Bakhtin 1935); cultivating and amplifying learners’ voices so they can speak truth to power. We developed and used a framework of learner’s voice to analyze the ways that youth from non-dominant raciolinguistic communities speak creatively, with resistance, and with transformative potential, from within cultural historical activity systems that mediate structures of racial domination.
The data included in this presentation arise from two very different contexts; a data literacy project within a middle school science classroom in the East Bay of California, and a hip-hop arts education intervention with youth in the West Bank of Palestine. Weaving between these two divergent contexts, we explore how youth in both learning environments seize opportunities to “call out” what is rigged. We explore a moment from the science classroom when young people call out their experience with fake science argumentation as “rigged.” After debating about what they had been told was a scientific controversy, they were shown a video from a science expert presenting the “answer.” The immediate response to the video was a collective calling out of “rigged” by a group of students. They break class culture to name the presentation of the video, and by implication, the argumentation unit, as deceitful and somehow stacked against them. In the context of Palestine we explore one of the products of the hip-hop workshop, a youth-designed rap video in which youth also point out “the rigged” in their social environment. A youth poet featured in the video draws on hybrid language practices (Gutierrez et al. 1999): two languages (Arabic and English), symbols and dialect from Black American hip-hop vernacular (Alim 2007), and local discourses from Palestinian political movements to call out the ways his environment has been rigged by the forces of Israeli occupation.
In this presentation we unpack what it means for students to voice their intuitions that systems are fixed, and how these voicings can be the blooming buds of more robust attempts to transform those systems. We find that the construct of “naming,” linked to Vossoughi’s (2014) notion of heteroglossic attunement, was profoundly helpful as a means of making visible the power, privileging, and source of racio-linguistic discourses, and their historical socio material mediation, by various intersecting, conflicting learning activity systems.
The data utilized in this study includes videotaped classroom interactions between students and teachers in both contexts. We also included youth produced work, including written assignments from the science course and a rap video produced for the hip hop project. Multimodal transcripts from both contexts were closed coded, according to a shared coding scheme so as to analytically explore how constructs like “naming” and “exposing the rigged” manifest in disparate learning ecologies.