Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objectives/Purpose. This paper furthers our understanding about the impact of the Indiana Choice Scholarship Program (ICSP) (vouchers) on high school students’ outcomes during high school and beyond. There is comparably little research on longer term degree attainment outcomes (e.g., high school graduation, college enrollment) (Betts & Tang, 2019; Shakeel et al., 2017) for voucher programs.
We focus on the following research questions:
• What is the impact of using a voucher to attend a private school in Indiana on student outcomes in high school (end of course assessments, retention, dropping out, and graduation) and beyond (two- or four-year college enrollment)?
• Are the voucher impacts greater for some groups of students compared with others in ways that change racial/ethnic and socioeconomic (SES) gaps in student outcomes?
Perspectives or Theoretical Framework. There are two competing theories that researchers and reformers use to explain student outcomes—market theory and institutional theory. On the one hand, market theory predicts that students attending charter or private schools will experience positive student outcomes because parents are choosing private schools that fit their child’s preferences (Chubb & Moe, 1990). On the other hand, institutional theorists argue that schools are likely to look more alike than different in terms of their organizational structure and processes, resulting in few differences in student outcomes in private and public high schools (see Austin & Berends, 2018).
Methods. We construct treatment samples of students who transition from a traditional public school in eighth grade to a voucher high school. In our analyses, we compare these voucher high school students to their eighth-grade public school peers with the same race/ethnicity, sex, and free or reduced-price lunch (FRPL) recipient status in the same year and traditional public school who attend a public high school the following year. For the matched voucher sample, we do not specifically match on FRPL status in eighth grade; rather, we constrain the public school comparison sample to students who are “voucher eligible,” as voucher eligibility directly corresponds to the threshold for eligibility for reduced-price lunch.
Data. We analyze nine years (2010-2011 school year through 2018-2019) of longitudinal, student-level records for this study, obtained through an established data-sharing agreement with the IDOE. The records contain information about students attending public and private schools (including voucher and non-voucher students), which participate in the state testing program, state end of course assessments, and other reporting on student outcomes. Indiana is unique because most private schools participate in the ISTEP+ program and other state reporting.
Results. As we recently received funding for this study from the Institute for Education Sciences (IES), we will conduct this analysis during the fall 2019 semester.
Scientific Significance. Although Indiana has the largest voucher program the U.S., there has been no research on student’s high school and postsecondary outcomes. As school choice programs continue to increase in number, there is a need to understand the effects on longer-term outcomes if we are to better advance sound practice and policy—especially as it relates to reducing educational inequalities.
Joseph Waddington, University of Kentucky
Mark Berends, University of Notre Dame
Joseph J. Ferrare, University of Washington - Bothell
Ron Zimmer, University of Kentucky