Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Sharing Power and Voice: The Challenge of Adult Roles in Youth Participatory Action Research

Sun, April 19, 8:15 to 9:45am, Virtual Room

Abstract

It is not unusual for schools to invite students to share their input in climate surveys or small groups in schools. However, spaces where students are given the space to research root causes of their experiences and then use that data to impact school policies and practice is less common; moreover, facilitating such opportunities is not a skill set included in educator preparation (Mitra, Serriere, & Stoicovy, 2012; Pearce & Wood, 2019, Zion, York, & Stickney, 2017; Zion, Allen, & Jean, 2015). This lack of preparation and familiarity can result in avoidable challenges that derail the process and further marginalize already minoritized students.
In this paper, we explore the experiences of students and adults who have been engaging in a student led action research process in their high school for the past two years, with a goal of addressing equity issues in their school by influencing policy and practice. We attend specifically to the tensions that arose during the process, as adults struggled to “step back” and share power and voice with students (Zion & Petty, 2013). Data includes field notes from student sessions and regular interviews and focus groups with students and adults.
The primary tension for participating adults was their fear of, and lack of experience in, talking about injustice. When students decided to focus on discrimination and bias, they were ready to talk about these issues and their complexities. Well meaning adults hindered the process because of their own discomfort and fear of allowing tension to exist. The students more readily understood that tension and progress always coexist in creating change.
Secondly, YPAR is an iterative process, that stands in contrast to the outcome-driven structure of schooling. Adults had a tendency to avoid the process, and focus on outcomes. For example, they tended to skip past the problem identification and root cause analysis stages of the work, to assume that surveys would be the best means to collect data, and to try to design surveys with an intervention already in mind, building questions that would justify their anticipated outcome. Students were more willing to follow the process, explore the problems, and to consider multiple forms of possible data collection.
Finally, adults’ fear of students “failure” (to make change, or to be heard) often got in the way of the work- their lack of faith led them to push for easy wins, and to avoid more challenging topics and processes.
Our research in this site shows that schools and educators that choose to include student led research in their reform work must work on building the skills and commitments of adults, or risk tokenizing the voices they hope to center. Ultimately, while the student work was powerful, it was the change in adults that is most impactful -- as they saw students be courageous enough to take on these issues and present their policy proposal to the entire staff, they began to truly share power and create space for voice in their school community.

Authors