Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Critical Race Theory Insights on Issues of Classroom Management

Mon, April 25, 9:45 to 11:15am PDT (9:45 to 11:15am PDT), SIG Virtual Rooms, SIG-Classroom Management Virtual Paper Session Room

Abstract

Critical Race Theory Insights on Issues of Classroom Management

Contemporary U.S. student populations are highly diverse, and scholars have detailed the implications this reality presents for classroom management (Gay, 2006; Milner, 2014). Although the demographics of students in schools is composed of an ever-increasing array of social identity axes, race has long constituted the single most problematic among them. A plethora of scholarship has laid bare how consequences for infractions of certain aspects of classroom management (e.g., discipline rules) differ both quantitatively and qualitatively depending on students’ racial backgrounds. The most punitive consequences such as office disciplinary referrals, and assignment to alternative school settings are experienced more frequently by racial and ethnic minority students (Annamma, 2016; DeMatthews et al., 2017; Dutil, 2020). Race has been isolated as an impactful factor in the enforcement of classroom management protocols, but that does not mean race operates in isolation. Instead, it often intersects with other social identity axes including gender, socio-economic status, and ability. How race intersects with other axes, and the inequities introduced and perpetuated as a result of those intersections, is a feature of scholarship relevant to all school personnel. Put differently, analysis of the structure and enforcement of classroom management protocols from a critical race lens has the potential to offer important insights into certain dynamics of school operations.
We reviewed a collection of empirical studies and conceptual papers published since 2014 where researchers and scholars drew directly on Critical Race Theory as a theoretical framework or methodological grounding to explore the nature of classroom management (e.g., discipline and behavior management protocols), and the place of race and racism therein. Studies ranged from ethnographic single-classroom cases to quantitative and mixed-methods analyses drawn from large, urban school districts. Among the Critical Race Theory concepts highlighted across the collection were the construction of race, whiteness as property, and counternarratives. Qualitative studies uncovered colorblind or race neutral ideology in the language, but not in the implementation or outcomes of school discipline policies. Overall, the collection exposes how extant ideas in schools regarding what constitutes appropriate student behavior and comportment (versus which students’ behavior and conduct are perceived to be at odds with those ideas) are based on and supported by historically entrenched stereotypes of different racial groups. Analyses of the beliefs and practices of school personnel, particularly those charged with punishing students found in violation of discipline and behavior policies, expose widespread support for, rather than a critique of, the status quo in schooling operations that has long perpetuated racist inequities. Racism has been insinuated in classroom management protocols in ways that are pernicious, and scholars describe how it is commonly supported by notions of maintaining safe school environments. Ultimately, through Critical Race Theory analyses, the presence of racism in classroom management is exposed even as its impact seems to be hidden in plain sight for far too many school personnel.
All the above issues will be discussed in this symposium presentation.

Author