Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Production of "Bad Children" and Youth Subculture in Migrant Schools in China

Mon, April 25, 2:30 to 4:00pm PDT (2:30 to 4:00pm PDT), SIG Virtual Rooms, SIG-International Studies Virtual Paper Session Room

Abstract

Existing research about youth subcultures in the wealthy English-speaking world mostly focuses on the production of polarized, oppositional or counter-school cultures among youth from subordinate or minority groups (e.g., MacLeod, 1987; Ogbu, 2008; Willis, 1977). Building upon this line of research, a growing body of literature in China reports the presence of oppositional behaviors in rural and migrant schools. Conceptually, this literature has been primarily concerned with whether these oppositional behaviors constitute counter-school cultures in the Chinese context (e.g., Li, 2016; Xiong et al., 2015; Zhou, 2011). While this approach has yielded research documenting important empirical realities in various communities, its narrow reliance on the counter-school culture framework precludes a full understanding of the production of youth subcultures in the contemporary Chinese context.
To broaden and deepen our understanding of the production of youth subcultures in China, we draw on the conceptual resources of cultural production theories (Weis et al., 1996). This approach emphasizes how individuals produce meanings and identities in relation to the contingencies and cultural dynamics of the specific local site as well as macro-level political, economic and socio-ideological formations.
We conducted a longitudinal ethnographic work at a migrant school in Guangzhou between January 2019 and June 2021, observing classes and extracurricular activities and interviewing students and teachers. We gradually identified two inter-related peer groups that were well-known as the “bad children” of the school and were frequently criticized and disciplined by teachers and administrators. We then followed these two friendship groups closely, observing their various out-of-school excursions and conducting intensive interviews with the core members to understand life histories.
Our findings demonstrate how the “hun rizi” (passing time) practices of the “bad children” and many of their academically disengaged peers (sleeping through classes, evading homework, skipping classes, etc.) constitute youth’s coping strategies in response to the alienating exam-oriented curriculum, unstable – sometimes antagonistic – student-teacher relationships, highly limited opportunity for academic success as well as discriminatory disciplinary practices that they experience at school. We also illustrate how the “bad children” proactively and creatively exercise agency to seek enjoyment, belonging, recognition and empowerment through their various “zhao lezi” (seeking fun) and entrepreneurial practices: playing basketball, roaming shopping malls, working in bars, and eventually starting their own electronic cigarette e-retail business. School administrators and teachers interpreted their “zhao lezi” activities as signs of moral corruption and imposed targeted monitoring and disciplinary measures, pushing them further away from the school system. Nonetheless, these engagements prepare them to join the city’s booming entertainment industry and Internet economy as consumers, workers, and entrepreneurs. In this process, they also formed stable friendship groups and extensive acquaintance networks, which they mobilize to solve various practical problems and expand economic opportunities.
Our study broadens the research on youth subcultures by illustrating the dynamic interplay of structural constraints and individual agency in the production of “hun rizi” and “zhao lezi” subcultures. It reveals the critical role of schools in producing “bad children,” thereby pointing to new possibilities of making schools more attractive and supportive spaces for underprivileged youth.

Authors