Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Sign In
When universities and schools shut their doors and moved all teaching activities online in March 2020 initial teacher education (ITE) providers across Ireland had to implement emergency alternative practicum supports in order to ensure that students could complete their ITE programmes.While schools reopened in September 2020, teacher educators continued to support new cohorts of student teachers in their academic as well as professional development, including their practical teaching in schools, through ‘disembodied’ online engagement. School visits were impossible for a full academic year. While virtual classroom observation could be arranged with some schools, significant administrative, legal and GDPR challenges necessitated an alternative approach to practicum supervision to allow flexible yet consistent support and fair assessment of all student teachers. Professional conversations between students and tutors, focused on placement experiences and learning, were introduced by many ITE providers across Ireland as an alternative to the traditional approach combining classroom observation with feedback discussions. It is easy to view the response to the crisis in purely deficit terms. For obvious reasons, no sensible teacher educator would advocate for abandoning school visits and replacing them with online professional conversations. Nonetheless, emergency measures arguably brought about affordances to the delivery of teacher education, which are deserving of consideration and may help to inform future practice. In this paper a multidisciplinary group of teacher educators, draw on our recent experience of ITE emergency practicum supervision to explore assumptions and tensions inherent in traditional teacher education practices. We reflect on ways in which we have, over the past year, built relationships with our students from a distance (on screen) and, in particular, how we enacted and experienced professional student-tutor conversations without the normally preceding classroom observations. We consider a range of probing questions that pertain to the development of mentoring relationships and practice learning during the crisis; for example, can “caring” mentoring relationships be fostered in disembodied learning environments? How did our teacher educator identities shift as we supported student teachers’ developing classroom practice without classroom observation? How were our professional conversations different in positive terms from our traditional school visits? In responding to these questions, we draw on our analysis of recordings and reflections from our multidisciplinary teacher educator group, notes from school placement tutor team meetings conducted over the 2020/21 academic year and summary reports prepared by students following the professional conversations. Key findings from our analysis highlight how the nature of student-tutor relationships changed this year. In discussing the findings we draw on theories of mentoring, practice learning and relatedness in education to interrogate normalised assumptions about the value and purpose of classroom observation. We share our perceptions regarding the effects that the change in practice had on student teachers and teacher educators.A key theme threading through our discussion relates to the negotiation of power and performativity in different learning environments. In our conclusion we consider how engagement between student teachers and mentors around practice learning and concerns can be enhanced through conversations in disembodied ‘third’ spaces.