Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Professional Shame as a Sociopsychological Experience: Insights From Studies in Engineering Education Research

Fri, April 22, 9:45 to 11:15am PDT (9:45 to 11:15am PDT), Manchester Grand Hyatt, Floor: 2nd Floor, Seaport Tower, Gaslamp CD

Abstract

The objectives of this presentation are to 1) provide definitional clarity concerning professional shame; 2) explore how this phenomenon has operated as a mechanism for inclusion and exclusion among engineering students; and 3) discuss how professional education cultures can leverage insights of professional shame to advance well-being and equity.

Anchored in theoretical foundations of psychology (de Hooge et al., 2011; H. B. Lewis, 1971; M. Lewis, 1995; McLean & Syed, 2015; Tangney & Dearing, 2002), sociology (Brown et al., 2006; Scheff, 2003), and in empirical foundations of prior work, I conceptualize professional shame to be characterized by four features:

(1) Individuals perceive themselves to have failed to meet socially constructed expectations that are relevant to their identities in a professional domain; (2) individuals experience a painful emotional state amid such perceived failure; (3) individuals attribute the failure to meet expectations to an inadequate whole, or global, self rather than a domain-specific feature of a certain identity; and (4) individuals within professional domains not only experience the emotional state of shame but also contribute to expectations that establish the conditions for professional shame to occur (Authors-1, 2021, p. 415).

My perspective of professional shame is informed by three studies (Authors-1, in press, 2020, 2021a, 2021b), in which colleagues and I used intensive qualitative methods to examine professional shame as experienced and constructed by engineering students. We conducted an interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) (Smith et al., 2009) of in-depth interview transcripts with engineering students who identified as White and male (n = 9) (Authors-1, 2021). We further conducted an ethnographic analysis of transcripts from focus groups (n = 10) with engineering students (n = 38) that were stratified to be both homogeneous and diverse in relation to gender and race categories (Authors-1, in press). Finally, we conducted an IPA of in-depth interview transcripts with engineering students who identified with marginalized gender and race categories (n = 7) (Authors-1, 2021b).

I emphasize three insights based on findings from these prior investigations. First, the processes that undergird professional identity development are intertwined with the holistic experience of professional shame. Second, individuals from marginalized social categories in professions are likely to experience shame in ways that mitigate their experience of belonging. Finally, professional programs can improve their underlying cultures of equity and belonging by modeling and teaching healthy strategies for experiencing shame, such as reframing the emotional experience and cultivating social connection.

Although prior literature on professional identity in engineering emphasizes how programs can instill a deeper sense of commitment to the profession (e.g., Godwin et al., 2016; Patrick et al., 2018) or how individual students may feel marginalized in engineering education (e.g., Foor & Walden, 2009; Hatmaker, 2013; Secules et al., 2018), we have rarely investigated the underlying emotions of professional formation. By understanding how shame is experienced in professional education and practice, educators may be purposeful about harnessing powerful moments for advancing individual well-being and equitable systems of belonging.

Author