Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Sign In
Despite ubiquitous acceptance of traditional views and definitions of mentoring and mentorship in teacher education, not all teachers have been equally served by these endeavors (Henning, Gut, & Beam, 2015; Russell and Russell, 2011). Unlike traditional approaches that lend themselves to institutional conformity through two person relationships, mentoring that considers race, culture, and collaborative work from the perspective of the mentee can produce positive results for teachers of color. Extant research involving Black and Latina beginning teachers suggests the benefits of holistic mentoring which considers the mind, soul, and body (Dingus, 2008) and collaborative mentorship which positions mentors and mentees as equal partners (Souto-Manning and Dice, 2007). The purpose of this study is to determine what happens when we expand traditional perspectives on a mentoring, and develop relationships grounded in a culturally responsive framework.
Theoretical Underpinnings
For the context of this study, we view mentorship through the paradigms of culturally responsive pedagogy and critical race theory. Culturally responsive pedagogy (CRP) centers the cultural insights and experiences of ethnically diverse populations as a basis for instruction. Just as the inclusion of student experiences into content makes what is taught more meaningful and accessible, we posit that a similar stance may benefit beginning teachers who are being mentored by others (Gay, 2002; (Ladson-Billings, 1995). Culturally Responsive Pedagogy provides us with a framework to acknowledge and appreciate our cultural differences and presence as a part of authentic mentorship. Similarly, we use Critical Race Theory to interrogate race, racism, and its implication on school practice and pedagogy (Howard and Navaro, 2016).
Methodology
In this three-person case study there are two levels of mentorship which take place between a teacher educator of color and a teacher leader as she progresses from a first to a third year teacher. The second level takes place between a teacher leader who mentors a third year teacher as he completes his third year of teaching. Mentorship in this study occurs in the form of interviews, observations, and classroom visits. Interactions focused on curriculum and pedagogy implementation, workplace interactions and promotion, and positioning based on gender, race, and class.
Findings
Our study resulted in three major themes: 1) Participants felt valued in their work with mentors of color. Both teachers felt that they were knowledgeable professionals whose ideas and opinions had merit and mattered. 2) Participants had increased agency and confidence to act using their own autonomy and discretion. Both teachers felt that school and state provided mentors expected them to conform to group norms even when it did not align with their personal teaching philosophies. 3) Participants were able to develop a trusting relationship with a mentor of color who they felt had their best interest in mind. The participants in this study not only, experienced the progression through formal, cordial, and friendship stages of mentorship (Henning, Gut, & Beam, 2015), but their mentoring interaction also transformed into a relationship based on equal roles of leadership and learning.