Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Career technical education is a matter of concern to industry leaders and others interested in the potential of education to serve a high-tech information economy. Efforts to promote career technical education have particularly targeted STEM-related coursework. In the context of these societal interests, our research sought to explore how high-level policy and educational aims may or may not translate into actual student experiences by examining trends in career technical education coursetaking. For this purpose, we used data from the NAEP High School Transcript Study, which includes coursetaking measures within career technical education subject areas spanning the time period from 1990 to 2019. One of the primary coursetaking measures included in this study – Carnegie credits earned by high school graduates – was used to analyze the number of career technical education courses taken by 2019 graduates based on a variety of variables, such as student race/ethnicity and gender, as well as geographic characteristics of the schools they attended. Additionally, trends since 1990 were probed by analyzing differences in the number of credits earned as well as the percentage of students who took courses in the delineated career technical education subject areas for each iteration of the transcript study.
Our findings show that there has been a decline in the overall average credits earned by high school graduates in career technical education courses since 1990. However, in accordance with the societal valuation of STEM-related career technical education, there has been a rise in areas such as health care sciences and engineering. Additionally, the area of information/computer technology has consistently been one of the most popular categories since 1990 in terms of the percentage of graduates who enroll in these courses. On the other hand, the most consistent decrease in both credits earned and percentage of graduates enrolled since 1990 are in categories associated with skilled trades such as construction and manufacturing – and much of this drop is attributable to the number of students who earned fewer than 2 credits in these subjects, indicating a decrease in casual or exploratory interest in these subjects. Additionally, a large decrease in the number of students taking business and marketing courses is primarily attributable to sharply declining enrollment in keyboarding and accounting courses.
Our analyses also indicate there is marked geographic variation in career technical education coursetaking patterns. In 2019, more credits were earned overall in the South Census region, as well as rural areas and towns (compared to suburbs and cities). However, in categories associated with traditional skilled trades, more credits were earned in the Midwest compared to other Census regions.
Finally, contrary to federal government policy aimed at achieving racial equity in career technical education, the 2019 transcript data does not show any general or widespread change in the racial/ethnic gaps in career technical education coursetaking. However, in light of substantial geographic variation in such coursetaking, further research exploring racial/ethnic differences within geographic categories may provide additional insights to inform these discussions.