Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Contextual Constraints for Youth Civic Engagement: Learning From Practicing Teachers and Imagining a Democratizing Response

Sat, April 15, 11:40am to 1:10pm CDT (11:40am to 1:10pm CDT), Sheraton Grand Chicago Riverwalk, Floor: Level 2, Superior A

Abstract

Objectives
This presentation analyzes the perspectives of practicing teachers working in schools that they perceived as unfriendly towards youth civic engagement while enrolled in a university-based class on the topic. We propose involving a greater range of stakeholders (e.g., colleagues, administrators) in learning experiences about civic education to address the dilemma these teachers faced and as a response with possible democratizing impacts on teacher education.

Perspectives
First, our work is grounded in the assumption that schools should be sites for youth civic engagement and a concern for the way that civic education is endangered, enacted inequitably (Rebell, 2018; Levinson, 2012), and lacks in critical relevance especially for students in marginalized communities (Clay & Rubin, 2020). Second, we view teachers’ work as socially mediated (Lave & Wenger, 1990) and impacted by varying contextual factors (Hochberg & Desimone, 2010). Finally, we value calls for the democratization of teacher preparation that engages varied clinical stakeholders (Zeichner et al., 2015), especially given the importance of administrators’ buy-in for school-based civic education (Kahne, Rogers, & Kawko, 2021; Kawashima-Ginsberg & Junco, 2018).

Methods and Data Sources
Our research participants were four teachers enrolled in a university-based class focused on K-12 action civics through which youth study and address authentic civic issues. Drawing on interviews from the beginning and end of the semester, 9 course assignments, and multiple emails exchanged post-semester, we used a collaborative coding process (Smagorinsky, 2008) to analyze teachers’ experiences. In this presentation, we focus on two teachers’ discussions of contextual constraints for action civics in their workplaces.

Conclusion
While the educators’ visions of teaching for civic engagement expanded while enrolled in the class, here we consider teachers’ struggle to teach accordingly. An early-elementary teacher described a teaching schedule that minimized time for social studies or civics education, reflecting broad trends (Fitchett & Heafner, 2010; Heafner, 2020), and pressure to improve students’ reading skills. The secondary teacher described a school culture that prioritized lectures, note-taking, and memorization. In civics class, her more-experienced co-teacher used a pre-planned unit-by-unit outline which led them to teach civics with academic detachment (Levine, 2011) and avoid students’ own civic literacies (Mirra & Garcia, 2020). Both teachers encountered a tension between the vision of civic engagement promoted in their university course and contextual realities in their schools. These experiences provoke renewed alarm in the role of restrictive curriculum and also lead us to propose incorporating broader coalitions from school communities, including administrators, in teacher education for youth civic engagement. We explore how teacher educators can facilitate exchanges that air potentially competing narratives and invite new ways forward.

Significance
Our presentation centers the lived experiences of practicing teachers, calls for greater inclusion of stakeholders in teacher education, and proposes the value of this inclusion to promote youth civic engagement. Furthermore, we advocate for stakeholder inclusion recognizing that stakeholders may oppose our vision for action civics. We nonetheless seek more diverse exchanges among stakeholders given their potentially democratizing effect on teacher education and role in possibly widening students’ access to relevant civics education.

Authors