Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Objectives
This paper employs the theoretical framework, “The Ethical Long View” (ELV), to explore what it means for teachers to be civic actors within a democratic society. This work frames the profession of teaching as being morally fraught: teachers are necessarily situated between competing and conflicting responsibilities. Understanding the profession in this way positions all teachers as reflective civic actors, working as mediators between the public (education as a democratic good) and private (education as a personal good) aims of schooling.
Perspectives
This paper is situated in the fields of teacher education and professional ethics. Philosophers point to the need to help educators attend to the “everyday dilemmas” that require them to “think carefully about the values and moral principles at stake” in the choices they make (Levinson & Fay, 2016, p. 2). In teacher education, there is increasing attention to preparing teachers to view their work as “an ethical and moral enterprise” (Bullough, 2011, p. 27), including professional development focused on ethical decision-making rather than behavior management (Orchard, Heilbronn, & Winstanley, 2016).
Modes of Inquiry
Our mode of inquiry is “empirically engaged philosophy” (Wilson & Santoro, 2015, p. 116). This method begins by identifying the “philosophical questions that emerge from the everyday lives of teachers and students” and, from there, moves toward arguments for what ought to be done (Wilson & Santoro, 2015, p. 116).
Data sources
We focus on the cases of two high school English teachers, Sylvester and Leslie. These teachers were two of 127 responses solicited from an online, national survey which asked K-12 teachers to share their answers to three open-ended questions related to a dilemma they faced as a teacher. We also conducted in-depth interviews with nine respondents, including Sylvester and Leslie.
Arguments
Central to this paper is a theoretical framework we call “The Ethical Long View” (ELV). We analyze the focal cases to show why and how using the Ethical Long View can help teachers better identify and respond to ethical dilemmas they face. The Ethical Long View requires teachers to be attentive to four ethical dimensions: Responsibility, Relationship, Time, and Justice. The paper introduces this framing, focusing on the Responsibility dimension, which shows the teacher’s position among competing obligations to parents, students, self, and policy.
Sylvester and Leslie, two politically liberal teachers teaching in politically conservative communities, both described dilemmas in which their views of good teaching, which Leslie described as wanting students to “to be aware of the social injustices around them based on race, gender identity/expression, sexual orientation” were constrained by implicit and explicit forces. We discuss how both acquiesce to these pressures–in different ways and for different reasons.
Scientific or scholarly significance
Using the ELV framework helps prepare teachers to make judgments that are both attentive to the needs of particular students and, at the same time, have broader ramifications on democratic society. Finally, the ELV provides an opportunity for teacher educators to engage preservice teachers in crucial discussions about the moral and ethical decision making in teaching.