Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Exploring the Relationship Between Two Tools for Noticing Critical Events of Students' Mathematical Thinking

Fri, April 14, 8:00 to 9:30am CDT (8:00 to 9:30am CDT), Swissôtel Chicago, Floor: Event Centre, 1st Floor, Montreux 2

Abstract

Objectives and Perspectives
While research has documented that teachers' noticing of students' mathematical thinking (SMT) supports student learning (e.g., National Council of Mathematics Teachers, 2014), less is known about how such noticing might be supported in the context of online professional development (PD).
In particular, video is a key resource for helping teachers learn to notice (Marsh & Mitchell, 2014; Ramos et al., 2021; Author et al., 2019), but as teacher learning experiences are increasingly offered in online contexts (Falk & Drayton, 2015), new questions arise about how to support teachers’ noticing via video in such formats. Building on sociocultural perspectives that highlight the role of tools as important mediators of activity and learning (see, for example, Cole & Engeström, 1993; Greeno, 2006), this study examines how the use of two tools (commenting and tagging) in an online video-based PD course supported teachers in noticing critical events of SMT.
Data Sources and Methods
Data come from an online PD course on mathematical argumentation in the early grades, in which teachers shared videos of their students engaged in argumentation tasks on an online platform. They then used a commenting tool that allowed them to view video in its entirety and write a summary note, and a tagging tool that allowed them to mark moments of video while viewing and associate notes with those moments.
We used ten K-2 teachers’ tags and comments as proxies for their noticing and examined the substance of all tags (n=233) and comments (n=57) they made. Segmenting tags and comments into idea units (Jacobs & Morita, 2002), we coded each idea unit across the dimensions of actor, topic, and whether their remarks were based on events from the video (Colleague & Author, 20xx). When idea units demonstrated the following cluster of codes — Actor: Student, Topic: Mathematical thinking, and Video-based: Yes — we called this cluster “Student Mathematical Thinking in the Video” (SMTV). Finally, we used bottom-up coding (Miles et al., 2018) to determine whether the substance of SMTV tags and comments were thematically connected, that is focused on the same critical events.
Results and Significance
We found that the tagging tool and commenting tool appeared to function in complementary but not always explicitly connected ways to support teachers’ noticing. Almost half of teachers’ SMTV comments connected directly to an SMTV tag they made about the same critical event. Yet about half of teachers’ SMTV comments were not connected to an SMTV tag in this way. In the full paper, we will further unpack the nature of “connected” and “not connected” SMTV comments and themes across the critical events noticed in connected as compared to not connected comments.
These results suggest that teachers became increasingly attuned to noticing SMTV through multiple mechanisms as they used the tools, contributing to the field’s growing understanding of how technological advances can support the development and study of mathematics teacher noticing.

Authors