Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Critical Descriptive Exploration of Black Boys' Well-Being in Early Childhood

Sun, April 16, 9:50 to 11:20am CDT (9:50 to 11:20am CDT), Sheraton Grand Chicago Riverwalk, Floor: Level 4, Chicago Ballroom VIII

Abstract

Objectives

Little is known about Black boys’ well-being in early childhood. While traditional developmental perspectives on social and emotional development offer some conceptual and empirical insight into the well-being of children, these perspectives paint a grossly incomplete and dehumanizing portrait of well-being for children of color (Camangian & Cariaga, 2018). As Black boys experience dehumanization in society during early childhood (Dumas & Nelson, 2016; Goff et al., 2014), understanding and promoting their well-being requires critical conceptual and methodological approaches that transcend disciplinary silos. This study utilizes a holistic conceptualization of childhood well-being to examine trends, contextual factors, and development processes related to preschool-age Black boys’ well-being. In this study, I ask: What key trends exist in preschool-age Black boys’ well-being?; and, Within home, school, and community environments, what are sources of vulnerability and resilience for Black boys’ well-being?

Theoretical Framework

This study integrates Morton-Manning’s (2014) and Lewis’ (2019) critical perspectives on childhood well-being; Weisner’s (1998) Ecocultural Development Framework, which asserts that culturally-specific routines and processes shape well-being; and Critical Bioecological Development (Vélez-Agosto et al., 2017), which asserts that culture informs the direction and impact of developmental processes that affect early outcomes such as well-being.

Data

This study utilizes the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study Birth Cohort (ECLS-B). ECLS-B collected data from a nationally representative sample of children from birth through the fall of their kindergarten year. This dataset provides information on children’s learning and development within homes, early childhood educational, and community contexts. The analytic sample used for this study consisted of 671 Black, 4-year-old boys.

Methods

To understand Black boys’ well-being as a phenomenon, I used Quantitative Descriptive Analysis (Loeb et al., 2017) to estimate descriptive information, including means, frequencies, variance, and cross tabulations on aspects of Black boys' well-being, and home, school, and community environments. Then, using Quantitative Criticalism (Stage & Wells, 2014) as a guide and the aforementioned theoretical frameworks, I selected items in ECLS-B to paint a holistic portrait of Black boys’ well-being during their preschool year.

Results & Significance

Preliminary results show variability in Black boys’ affective and relational well-being by social factors such as SES, geography, and urbanicity. Further, when utilizing a holistic and critical measure of well-being, Black boys’ well-being illuminates areas of resilience and vulnerability, as opposed to only vulnerability, which traditional, normative conceptualizations and measures of well-being document. Finally, homes, schools, and community contexts provide sources of resilience and vulnerability for Black boys’ early well-being. For example, over half (58%) of Black boys live in households rich with developmental practices that foster their affective and relational well-being. However, over half (56%) of Black boys live in communities that lack the institutions and spaces that foster well-being.

This study highlights the utility and relevance of a holistic measure of well-being that captures the sociocultural nature of well-being. As such, study findings provide more relevant knowledge that can guide research, policy and learning, and developmental practice that specifically and effectively set Black boys on a trajectory of life-long well-being.

Author