Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Measuring Black Student Safety: Using Higher-Order Confirmatory Factor Analysis to Validate a New Measure With the California Healthy Kids Survey

Sun, April 16, 9:50 to 11:20am CDT (9:50 to 11:20am CDT), Sheraton Grand Chicago Riverwalk, Floor: Level 4, Chicago Ballroom VIII

Abstract

Objectives
Research has well-documented racism as a pervasive barrier to equitable schooling for Black youth (Bonilla-Silva, 2018; Blaisdell, 2015; Howard, 2010; Kohli et al., 2017). Even so, frameworks and measures for assessing school climate and safety remain colorblind and have yet to operationalize the impact of institutional racism on Black youths’ feelings of school safety (Edwards, 2021). This study shows how applying a racial lens to assessing Black youths’ feelings about school safety can provide novel and valuable insight into relevant factors that influence their safety and overall well-being—factors that would otherwise go unnoticed via traditional colorblind safety measures.

Theoretical Framework
This study draws from Edwards (2021) Intersectional Ecological Framework for Defining School Safety for Black Students. Edwards (2021) posits that ensuring Black students’ safety necessitates a comprehensive definition of safety and highlights six critical dimensions to consider: racial-cultural, gender and queer identity, academic, social-emotional, interpersonal, and physical safety. Building from Edwards (2021), this study provides evidence to support a multidimensional measure of Black Student Safety.

Data
Data for this quantitative cross-sectional study come from the 2017-2018 and 2018-2019 high school administration of the California Healthy Kids Survey (CHKS)—the largest state-wide student survey of resiliency, protective factors, risk behaviors, and school climate in the nation. The state representative analytic sample consisted of 877 Black 9th graders from 65 public schools in California.

Methods
This study used a racial lens to reconfigure items from CHKS to capture the racialized experiences of Black youth in school. Restructured items were used in a Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) examining Black Student Safety as a higher-order latent construct with four factors: racial-cultural safety, academic safety, physical-environmental safety, and perceptions of school police. Multilevel modeling was then used to test the extent to which factors of the new higher-order construct predicted important psychosocial outcomes for Black youth like caring relationships at school, academic motivation, and aspirations.

Results & Significance
Results for the CFA confirmed the hypothesized multifactorial structure of Black Student Safety with significant loadings above the .30 threshold and acceptable global fit statistics (CFI=.940, TFI=.928, SRMR=.077, RMSEA=.072). Further, Black Student Safety predicted feelings of school safety, and specific factors were significantly and positively associated with important outcomes. For example, feelings of racial-cultural and academic safety strongly predicted Black youths’ academic motivation and their perceptions of caring relationships at school. Similarly, academic and physical-environmental safety strongly predicted Black youths’ goals and aspirations.

This study interrupts the colorblind discourse of school climate and safety to address institutional racism in schools as a threat to Black youth. Further, it responds to an urgent call for comprehensive measures of school safety that more accurately capture the experiences of Black youth (Edwards, 2021; Heidelburg et al., 2022). Black Student Safety can be used to inform future research, original instrument development, and school-based practice to ensure the safety and wellness of Black youth.

Author