Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Objectives
This paper sets the framework for the session’s overall focus on racial contestation and learning across multiple racialized groups/communities. It also highlights the Spencer-funded research conference framing and lessons learned from the overall conference.
Framework
Racial contestation was named by sociologist Nicholas Vargas (2014) when describing how demographic data captured in sizable national surveys illustrated a mismatch between racial categorization and ascribed race. It can be extended to individuals’ identities (Rockquemore et al., 2009) and researchers’ conceptualizing of such categories (Saperstein & Penner, 2012, 2014). This phenomenon connects with being in a state of racial liminality (Brunsma et al., 2013), which signals the existing “in between” or outside of popular conceptions of race and the racial categories currently employed in higher education research and practice. Mohajeri (in press) connected racial contestation to whiteness-as-property (Harris, 1993) and argued that there is a contest at play along the borders of racial categories, a competition which distributes the spoils of white supremacy – including “dominance, normativity, privilege, and belonging” (p. 9) along the alignment or misalignment of the subcategories of race.
Modes of inquiry
In order for the framework of racial contestation to lead to real change, we must first examine power dynamics associated with who (or more appropriately from what social location) is doing the contesting. Racial contestation can come from individuals, such as friends or acquaintances. It can manifest in systems and institutional logics, and it can emerge from social forces and mental models. In order to better organize these dynamics, we outline two different axes of power that must be further considered: (a) a vertical axis of power traditionally associated with racial hierarchies within a white supremacist society; and (b) a horizontal axis aligned with prototypicality, or how central a particular (sub)group is to the most ascendent or referent members of the group (often not positioned as subgroups at all, but as the whole).
Evidence
We highlight tensions and learning points from our discussions from the Spencer-funded conference on racial contestation. There are benefits of learning across communities toward understanding how our truths might be grounded in particular communities and how we can stimulate new truths through dialogue and solidarity building. For instance, when are Latinx/a/o/e students counted as Indigenous? How should Native American students not even be included in “racial and ethnic” conglomerations given sovereignty that reflects more of a citizenship status/relationship to the U.S. government? How do we make sense of the increasing multiple race/ethnicity and unknown populations of students?
Significance
By critically engaging the questions posed above, our paper demonstrates learning edges that we share with AERA audiences to continue stimulating critical views of the normative racial/ethnic categories most often used in education research. It provides a common ground for the other presentations and foundation for a generative audience discussion.