Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Purpose
While we commonly treat humans as having agency—and even define agency as a human property—research on design has long troubled this notion by treating designing as a conversation with materials (Schön, 1992). From this stance, the materials we offer learners might be unalterable, used functionally but unchanged, or modified dramatically in use (Svihla et al., 2020). In this paper, we examine ways learners treated various materials in a designed paper computing kit. Specifically, we investigated:
● How do learners negotiate their agency with materials in the context of an informal STEM camp focused on making and radio communications?
Theoretical framework
Posthumanist design looks at design not only in the context of humans, but in the relationships between humans and non-human artifacts (Forlano, 2017). In decentering humans, we consider the ways materials have agency imbued by their creation and form (Knappett & Malafouris, 2008; Pickering, 1993). In problem contexts, multiple agencies exist in tension both from human and non-human agents (Erofeeva, 2019).
Designers decide not only how to arrive at a solution, but the attributes of the solution . We term the ability to make decisions about how to approach a problem as framing agency (Svihla et al., 2021). We pair this with the idea that computing and technology is learned through the lens of students’ own perspectives and cultures (Jackson, 1993; Scott et al., 2015).
Method & Data sources
We conducted this study as first-cycle design-based research (The Design-Based Research Collective, 2003) aiming to theorize human and material agency. We collected video recordings, interviews, and artifacts of youth participation in a week-long camp. We selected focal students for the current study to highlight variability (N=4).
The camp aims to develop student understanding of wireless radio communication through making. We used micro:bits, the small, BBC-developed computer with its block programming software (Austin et al., 2020) and my:Talkies: a pair of paper templates a micro:bit is mounted into and then folded into a box. The established nature of the my:Talkies indicate they have high agency (White, 2019) and could be potentially coercive.
Students were posed a design scenario for a community in their town in need of radio communication systems. Students completed a pre-ideation activity focused on supporting creativity and empathy (Svihla & Kachelmeier, 2022) before individually planning (Anderson et al., 2017). They had several hours over two days to develop and create their solution. The constraints included needing to communicate to another micro:bit.
Substantiated conclusions & Scholarly significance
Students received the same context and base papercraft form (my:Talkies), however, students created a divergent set of designs (Figure 5). They showed low agency over the base form of the my:Talkies, not altering the paper itself. However, they demonstrated their negotiated agency through adding to the my:Talkies and through the coding process. Using the scenario of designing for a city’s future, students generated unique pro-social narratives. The inputs and outputs provided on the micro:bit (i.e. accelerometer, LED) also allow students to make choices.