Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Mobbing as Moral Technology: The Political Utility of Managing Fairness

Sun, April 16, 8:00 to 9:30am CDT (8:00 to 9:30am CDT), Sheraton Grand Chicago Riverwalk, Floor: Level 2, Colorado

Abstract

In a recent chapter on workplace mobbing, Authors 1&2 explored “fairness technologies” - the array of mediating tools and structures through which organizations attempt to ensure fair play for employees (2021). These include policies and procedures around hiring, performance and promotion review, formal roles and structures advancing diversity, equity and inclusion, etc. The first paper introduces mobbing as a form of workplace aggression. To set the stage for the varied accounts of mobbing, Author 1&2 define and interrogate how fairness technologies function and dysfunction, how they are undermined and co-opted.

As a form of workplace aggression, mobbing targets collective hostility with the intent to drive out or marginalize another employee (M Duffy & Sperry, 2012). Cornoiu and Gyorgy (2013) describe it as “professional, psychological and social destruction of the victim” (p. 711) enacted through “a series of persecutions, attacks and humiliations that occur slowly, subtly and persist for a long time” (p. 712). Interest in mobbing emerged in the wake of a global shift toward neoliberal management (Erdemir et al., 2020; Vandekerckhove & Commers, 2003). Neoliberal reform was not confined to the U.S., but organizational conditions ripe for mobbing may prevail in the American context valorizing rugged individualism and downplaying corporate and employer responsibility (M Duffy & Yamada, 2018). Mobbing only recently garnered academic attention in the US (Yamada et al., 2018), and remains under-theorized due to a practical focus on treating and heading off the related trauma (Branch et al., 2013; Nielsen & Einarsen, 2018). To elucidate the emergence of mobbing with neoliberal reforms, Authors 1&2 (2021) used Stephen J. Ball’s work on educational micropolitics and managerialism.

Mobbing and workplace bullying are often used interchangeably (Sperry, 2009). However, Duffy and Sperry (2012) distinguish mobbing by its organizational dimensions and situatedness: “Unlike bullying, mobbing is a systemic phenomenon that involves the interplay of organizational, group, and individual dynamics and behavior” (p. 4). Highlighting the interplay of individual, group, and organizational behaviors and dynamics, their distinction highlights the political character of the phenomenon. A mobbing is undoubtedly, and by design, characterized by incivility, and may derive from psycho- or socio-pathologies. However, to view it solely as aberrant, pathological, and unproductive behavior obscures key political dimensions. Mobbing is political, especially when management simultaneously activates, depoliticizes, and denies it. By drawing attention to the interplay of interests, conflict and power in mobbing, micropolitical analyses foreground and make sense of the backstage interplay of individual, group and organizational dynamics (Ball, 1989). Centering the political reveals the instrumental use of the practice—implemented as a moral technology (Ball, 1990)—as a form of social control to shape and manage the reform of educational work and workers (Ball, 2016). This illuminates the political utility of the administrative displacement of conflict to backstage spaces that “inadvertently reinforce[s] bullying and mobbing behavior” particularly in “[o]rganizational cultures that support a veneer of civility” (Sloan et al., 2010, pp. 91–92).

Authors