Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Policies and practices implemented at historically and predominantly white institutions (HPWIs: diversity and inclusion initiatives, public statements, diversity programming) often serve to portray the racial climate as anti-racist. As such, these institutional actions can operate as master narratives (Solórzano & Yosso, 2002) and effectively obscure the racial realities of non-dominant student populations. The purpose of this presentation is to critically interrogate dominant forms of truth by analyzing the ways in which Black students experience policies and practices designed to enhance the racial climate at one large public HPWI. In doing so, this presentation redefines experiential truth from a Black perspective and offers insight into how institutions can reimagine policies and practices that are humanizing and liberatory for Black students (Savage et al., 2021).
This presentation draws upon the following framing ideas proposed by Dumas & Ross (2016) to analyze and make meaning of how Black students experience institutional policies and practices designed to enhance the racial climate. First, BlackCrit asserts that anti-Blackness is central to making meaning of foundational dimensions of human life. Second, BlackCrit challenges claims of an anti-racist and egalitarian society. Thirdly, BlackCrit offers space to imagine Black liberation and triumph by disrupting dominant narratives that exonerate whites from a legacy of racial oppression.
A qualitative instrumental case study approach was used to examine how Black students experience institutional policies and practices. According to Stake (1995), an instrumental case study aims to garner insight into a problem by investigating a particular case. The case centered within this presentation is bounded within1 large northeastern HPWI. At the time of data collection, 46,723 students were enrolled at the University. Black undergraduate students represented 4.1% of the student body.
Data were pulled from a larger empirical research study which included a total of 20 semi-structured, virtual, one-on-one interviews with 10 Black students at a large northeastern PWI. Each participant met the following inclusion criteria: a) self-identified as Black/African American, (b) undergraduate student status, and (c) enrolled during data collection.
This presentation shows that participants experienced institutional policies and practices designed to enhance the racial climate as anti-Black. Indeed, participants reported gross incongruences between institutional commitments to anti-racism and their racial realities. More specifically, insights from this study indicated that institutional policies and practices implemented to support students of color function to communicate anti-Blackness.
The scholarly significance of this presentation takes on heightened importance as institutional policy and practice have been shown to impact key developmental outcomes for Black undergraduates (Strayhorn, 2009: Johnson & Kenney, 2021). Thus, this presentation can be used to reframe how institutional policies and practices can serve to humanize and promote belongingness among Black undergraduates.