The Other Side of the Tracks: How Academic Streaming Impacts Student Relationships

• In Event: Enacting Curriculum Policy Reform With Equity and Inclusion Goals: Exploring Barriers and Possibilities

Abstract

While the inequitable academic impacts of curricular tracking are well understood, less attention has been paid to its social impacts. Utilizing focus groups and in-depth interviews with students and parents in a low-income neighbourhood in Toronto, Canada, this paper uses social identity theory to explore how tracking impacts the nature of relationships between students in different tracks. Findings include that tracking contributed to widening social divides between students, working to replicate and reinforce social stratification, with negative consequences falling most heavily on those assigned to lower tracks. Students formed friendships primarily with same-track peers, while negative stereotyping and bullying across tracks was common. Tracking also increased racial divisions, which led to geographic segregation and schools becoming a racially divided space.

Authors

• Sachin Maharaj, University of Ottawa

• Sana Zareey, University of Toronto