Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Federal college access programs have been proposed for elimination on the argument that access to college is no longer the main obstacle for low-income students. Using the High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 and doubly robust estimators with machine-learned nuisance models, this study compares three federal programs (Talent Search, Upward Bound, GEAR UP) with two non-profit alternatives (AVID, MESA) and with non-participation, on outcomes spanning the high-school-to-college pipeline. Talent Search participation is associated with 5.9 percentage points higher college entry, but beyond entry, federal participants are indistinguishable from non-participants. Head-to-head, federal participants outperform non-profit participants in advanced high school science credits and mathematics grades, selective four-year enrollment, and college science credits attempted and earned. These gaps arise because non-profit participants fall below comparable non-participants. The gaps are sensitive to modest unobserved differences and smaller and less precise when survey-weighted. The results do not support treating the non-profit programs observed here as substitutes for federal programs, and effects differ enough across programs that funding decisions are better informed program by program than for programs as a class.