Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Country social cost of carbon estimates and their application to assess the natural land sink

Thursday, November 5, 3:30 to 5:00pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: MIT

Abstract

Land ecosystems absorb roughly 2.21 gigatons of carbon dioxide per year. This sequestration mitigates climate change and the corresponding harms to human well-being. Yet, as climate policies increasingly rely on forests and other land-based carbon sinks, their benefits remain diffuse, unevenly distributed, and poorly quantified in national wealth accounts. This creates a central policy problem: countries that protect forests do not necessarily capture, and thus internalize, most of the corresponding climate benefits. This complicates the design of effective international payment and burden-sharing schemes. This is especially salient given recent COP30 efforts to advance international mechanisms for financing forest protection, including tropical forests.
This paper asks two related questions. First, how much are natural land sinks worth, and to whom? Second, how should that value be used to structure payments that incentivize forest protection? To address these questions, we derive novel estimates of country-level social costs of carbon (CSCC) and apply them to quantify how the wealth value of land carbon sinks is distributed across and between nations.
We use country-level carbon flux data from the Global Carbon Budget, averaged over 2013–2022 to minimize interannual variability, covering up to 214 countries. These data include natural land sink estimates under three land-cover assumptions (pre-industrial, present-day forest area, and managed forest), land-use change emissions from four bookkeeping models, and fossil fuel emissions. CSCC estimates are derived using 210 CMIP5 climate models paired with 1,000 bootstrapped draws of the econometric damage function to capture both climate system and parameter uncertainty.
We derive CSCCs within the Ricke et al. (2018) framework, updated with the convergence-consistent damage function of Harding et al. (2025). These CSCCs are embedded in an inclusive wealth framework to decompose each country's carbon flux contribution into global, domestic, outbound (benefits flowing to other countries), and inbound (benefits received from abroad) components. The balance of transboundary contributions is then used to derive bilateral and multilateral payment estimates for forest preservation.
We estimate a median global SCC is US$167 per tCO₂. India has the highest CSCC (US$50 per tCO₂), while Russia (–US$6) and Canada (–US$2) show negative CSCCs. The global natural land sink contributes a median US$495 billion per year to global inclusive wealth after netting land-use change emissions. Countries most vulnerable to climate change, such as India, Nigeria, and China, receive the largest inbound wealth flows from forests abroad. Under a global multilateral agreement, Brazil could receive approximately US$202 per hectare per year for standing forest protection; in a bilateral arrangement with India alone, that figure is US$91 per hectare per year.
These findings provide a rigorous basis for forest finance mechanisms and show that meaningful payments for forest protection are feasible even without universal multilateral participation. This is a key finding in the context of current fractured global climate cooperation, including the U.S. withdrawal from the Paris Agreement. The inclusive wealth framework also enables countries to incorporate natural land sinks into comprehensive development accounting, correcting a systematic undervaluation of forest-rich nations in conventional GDP-based metrics.

Author