Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Updating the Workforce Almanac: Who are Eligible Training Providers and What Do They Train For?

Friday, November 6, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 1st Floor/Lobby Level, Room: Boylston

Abstract

Background: Short, job-focused postsecondary programs offered by a diverse mix of non-profit and for-profit providers have become prominent pathways into higher-wage careers. Learners engage inside and outside traditional institutions: 40 percent of undergraduates (9 million) are in certificate and associate programs at community colleges (Irwin et al., 2022; CCRC, 2023), almost 8 million people have enrolled in more than 70,000 publicly funded training programs since 2020 (DOL, 2026), and over 600,000 people participate in Registered Apprenticeships (DOL, 2024). Public and private spending on workforce development and education exceeds $130 billion annually (Credential Engine, 2021). Yet, despite their scale, system-level information on U.S. workforce training remains fragmented. 

Research Questions: This paper examines variation in training provider and program characteristics. Workforce training programs include certificate and associate degree programs, apprenticeships, programs eligible for federal funding under the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA), and other training non-profit organizations. We ask: (1) Which states have more access to workforce training options, and how does this access vary by program type, length, and occupation?; and (2) Do programs train for locally in-demand jobs?  

Methods: We create and use the Workforce Almanac, a novel provider- and program-level dataset that collates subsets of four publicly available datasets to capture more than 20,000 short-term workforce training providers and 200,000 programs across educational settings. The Almanac presents the most comprehensive, cross-sector view of the workforce training ecosystem to date, enabling analysis across training types that are typically examined in isolation. We combine the Almanac with state-level labor market data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Projections Central, and the United States Census Bureau. We first describe the most prevalent providers and programs by state, identifying which occupations are in-demand. We then estimate a series of linear regressions that model access to workforce training programs as a function of state-level characteristics. 

Results: Only 29 percent of total training providers are eligible for WIOA funding. The remainder of the workforce training sector captured in the Almanac is not WIOA eligible, including higher education institutions (18 percent), job training non-profits (37 percent), and Registered Apprenticeships (16 percent). The Midwest has the largest share of workforce training providers adjusting for size of the labor force. Washington D.C. has 35 providers per 100,000 people in the labor force, the most of any state, and Texas and Nebraska have the lowest ratios. Preliminary program-level findings suggest that programs are most likely to train workers to be heavy and tractor-trailer truck drivers, nursing and medical assistants, Registered Nurses, general and operations managers, and welders. These occupations are in-demand in some states, but not all.  

Implications: Short-term training programs provide critical opportunities to workers looking to reskill or upskill, and to employers looking to fill hiring gaps. While WIOA is a critical component of the workforce development ecosystem, looking at WIOA-eligible providers in isolation misses more than 70 percent of providers. As short-term Pell and other public investments increase, states and the federal government should work together to create and hone completion and quality metrics.

Author