Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Does Who You Train With Matter? Evidence from Medical Training and Patient Outcomes

Saturday, November 7, 1:45 to 3:15pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 5th Floor, Room: Maine

Abstract

Persistent racial disparities in U.S. healthcare remain a central policy concern. Black mortality has been 17-34% higher than non-Hispanic White mortality since 2018, and minority populations receive worse care across 30-43% of quality measures. A growing literature documents that physician-patient racial concordance improves health outcomes for minority patients, yet minorities remain severely underrepresented in medicine. This paper examines whether the training environment shapes physician effectiveness, asking: do physicians who trained alongside more minority peers deliver better outcomes for minority patients later in practice? We construct a novel physician-patient dataset linking three administrative sources. AAMC cohort data (2014-2023) provide annual racial composition of graduating classes for all U.S. medical schools. The Florida Physicians' Workforce Survey (FPWS) contains physician demographics and detailed residency training records for over 115,000 physicians. Florida AHCA Hospital Inpatient Data (2016-2023) provide patient demographics, diagnoses, and outcomes linked to treating physicians. We construct physician-level peer exposure indices capturing horizontal exposure to minority co-residents, cohort composition at entry, and vertical exposure to minority senior residents. Our fixed-effects specification regresses patient-level outcomes on physician peer exposure, an indicator for minority patients, and their interaction, controlling for medical school and residency program fixed effects, hospital fixed effects, physician fixed effects, year fixed effects, and a rich set of patient and physician characteristics. To address non-random sorting of patients to physicians, we develop an instrumental variables strategy exploiting quasi-random variation in physician scheduling within hospitals. The instrument uses the share of on-duty physicians at a given hospital, weekday, and hour who trained in high-diversity environments. Conditional on hospital-by-time fixed effects, this staffing composition generates plausibly exogenous variation in exposure to high-diversity physicians. Across both fixed-effects and IV specifications, we find that non-Black physicians who trained alongside more Black peers during residency deliver significantly better outcomes for Black patients. The residency peer exposure index, measuring the fraction of a physician's overlapping training time spent with Black co-residents, is associated with reduced Black patient mortality, and IV estimates confirm a significant interaction effect. We find parallel effects for senior peer exposure, with non-Black physicians mentored by Black senior residents also showing improved outcomes for Black patients. Exploring mechanisms, we find no evidence that peer exposure improves clinical knowledge or resource utilization. Effects appear to operate through trust and communication, as measured by reductions in patients leaving against medical advice. These findings suggest that diversifying residency training programs may generate positive spillovers for minority patient care well beyond the direct effects of physician-patient racial concordance.

Authors