Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Effect of a Promise Scholarship: Evaluating Indiana's 21st Century Scholars Program

Friday, November 6, 3:30 to 5:00pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Berkeley

Abstract

A central question in education policy is whether need-based financial aid can reduce persistent socioeconomic gaps in college enrollment and degree attainment. This study uses linked administrative data on educational and labor market outcomes to examine the impact of a need-based, first-dollar, post-secondary promise scholarship in Indiana: the 21st Century Scholars program (21C). This program provides a useful setting for studying whether need-based financial aid can narrow socioeconomic gaps in college enrollment and completion in a state with relatively low postsecondary attainment. Our empirical strategy makes use of an unusual feature of the program’s income-based eligibility criteria and hard enrollment deadline at the end of 8th grade. We use as-good-as-random variation in the timing of family income shocks during middle school to identify the causal impact of the program on college enrollment, degree completion, and early-career earnings. Specifically, we compare otherwise similar students whose family income qualifies them for the program during the middle-school application window with students whose income shocks occur outside that window, leaving later educational trajectories plausibly unaffected except through scholarship access. Our analysis uses administrative records for the 2012–2016 Indiana public high school graduation cohorts, linking K–12 schooling, postsecondary attainment, and quarterly earnings outcomes. We find that the relationship between income eligibility and 21C scholarship receipt varies substantially across school districts, suggesting that local differences in program implementation and take-up mediate the program’s impacts in the full sample. In schools where income-eligibility predicts program takeup, we estimate that enrolling in the program during middle school increases college enrollment by 6.8 percentage points (10% of the baseline 67%) and increases the probability of earning a Bachelor’s degree or higher by 4.3 percentage points (22% of the baseline 19%). These effects imply that promise scholarships can generate meaningful gains in postsecondary attainment when eligible students successfully enroll in and access the program. We find no clear short-run effects on early-career earnings, suggesting that labor market returns may take longer to emerge.

Author