Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Immigration Enforcement Actions and Empty Desks: Persistent and Acute Attendance Effects

Saturday, November 7, 1:45 to 3:15pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Tufts

Abstract

The return of the Trump administration in January 2025 ushered in a sharp escalation of federal immigration enforcement. The administration rescinded long-standing "sensitive locations" guidance that limited enforcement near schools, hospitals, and religious centers; expanded the use of expedited removal; and directed substantially increased resources toward interior enforcement operations. Arrests by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) rose markedly relative to the prior year, and high-profile operations in cities across the country generated media coverage and community alarm. These policy shifts have renewed long-standing concerns about spillover effects on children in immigrant families, including at least 4 million U.S. K–12 students who are undocumented and/or live with an undocumented household member (“mixed-status families”). Schools are a critical site for these spillovers: missed school days erode learning and raise the risk of disengagement, dropout, and poor health, with downstream consequences for students' long-run economic mobility and the broader social returns to public education. Yet existing evidence on how this new enforcement environment affects student attendance remains limited, and most prior studies rely on coarse demographic proxies for student vulnerability that likely attenuate estimated effects.
This paper examines how immigration enforcement actions (IEAs) affected daily attendance among students in “Liberty City,” a small urban postindustrial northeastern district whose experiences of intensified federal enforcement following the policy shift mirrored those of school communities across the country. We combine student-level administrative panel data containing daily attendance records with a precisely dated timeline of local IEAs assembled from community-sourced reporting and federal FOIA records. A central methodological contribution is our use of student birthplace as a direct proxy for vulnerability to enforcement, which is sharper than the language- and program-based proxies common in prior studies.
We estimate difference-in-differences and event study specifications with student and calendar-day fixed effects, comparing foreign-born and U.S.-born students before and after the onset of intensified enforcement. We find that foreign-born students experienced a persistent increase in daily absence rates of approximately 2.2 percentage points (37% increase over the pre–treatment mean) relative to their U.S.-born peers. This persistent effect dominates the response with event-study estimates around individual IEAs showing only modest and inconsistent acute spikes; this indicates that the dominant mechanism is a sustained behavioral shift rather than transient day-of disruption. Effects are largest in the elementary grades. Results are robust to alternative treatment definitions based on language status and recent immigrant designation, all of which attenuate toward zero relative to the birthplace-based estimate, consistent with measurement error in conventional proxies. A selective attrition analysis shows that foreign-born students became less likely to disenroll during the enforcement period, ruling out downward bias from differential exit.
Our findings suggest that the post-January 2025 enforcement environment has imposed meaningful and persistent educational costs on immigrant-origin students, operating primarily through sustained behavioral change rather than acute response to individual events. These findings are consequential for state-level law- and policy-making efforts to restrict schools’ and local law enforcement agencies’ ability to cooperate with ICE on or near school grounds.

Author