Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
In response to recent concerns about potential teacher shortages, many states have relaxed their teacher certification requirements. A growing body of work has examined specific state responses and their effects on the teacher workforce and student outcomes (e.g., Backes & Goldhaber, 2024; Chi et al., 2025), finding that temporary-licensed teachers don’t necessarily lead to different student outcomes but are more likely to leave than their traditionally licensed counterparts. A current gap in this research is how these temporary-licensed teachers might relate to non-academic outcomes for students – in particular, exclusionary discipline outcomes (e.g., in-school suspension, out-of-school suspension, expulsion).
To examine how these temporary-licensed teachers might be related to the likelihood of students receiving exclusionary discipline outcomes, we draw from Maryland state administrative records for the 2017-18 through 2023-24 school years and ask the following research questions:
Are students more likely to experience exclusionary discipline if their teacher has not completed formal training programs?
Does the presence of temporary licensed teachers contribute to disproportionalities in the use of exclusionary discipline?
Preliminary findings indicate that about 2% of observations (i.e., student-years) receive at least one exclusionary discipline outcome. We also find that students are more likely to receive exclusionary discipline when they are exposed to a teacher with a temporary teaching license. Specifically, we find that students exposed to a temporary licensed teacher are 0.4 percentage points more likely to experience an exclusionary discipline outcome overall. However, this relationship appears to vary slightly by student ethnoracial identity, with the overall finding being driven primarily by Black students (i.e., 1.0 pp). Further, we find that male students are about 0.9 pp more likely to experience exclusionary discipline when exposed to a conditionally certified teacher, and we find no relationship for female students.
The findings suggest that policymakers and practitioners should focus on additional professional development for these conditionally certified teachers. Conditionally certified teachers may benefit from differential classroom management training that focuses on addressing specific student behaviors. As these teachers have yet to complete their coursework, it is likely that they have not yet developed all the skills required for effective classroom management by the time they are hired. Before the APPAM conference, we plan to further explore how temporary licensed teachers in Maryland are associated with student test-score outcomes and how their likelihood of turnover compares to traditionally licensed counterparts.