Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Poster #50 - Documenting state-level policies: An updated framework for large-scale, longitudinal policy data construction

Saturday, November 7, 12:00 to 1:30pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Grand Ballroom - Salon EFG

Abstract

Background
As national interest in CS education increases, many states have adopted policies promoting K-12 computer science (CS) education. Efforts to document these policies (e.g., Code.org et al., 2023; CSTA Certification Committee, 2013) provide limited detail on adoption and implementation timing and information on data validity.

Addressing these gaps, we constructed the Computer Science Education Policy (CSEP) dataset, a national dataset on the adoption and implementation of nine state-level CS education policies across all 50 states and D.C. We also refined procedures for data collection, verification, and validation that guided our work and can serve as an example for systematic policy data collection in education and beyond.

Methodology 
Our CSEP data document nine state-level policies recommended by Code.org (2017), spanning from 2000-2001 to 2022-2023, including State plan, Standards, Funding, Certification, Preparation, CS position, HS requirement, Graduation, and Admission.

We collected data using two concurrent approaches: a legislative database search (via HeinOnline) for the State plan, Standards, Funding, CS position, HS requirement, Graduation, and Admission, and an internet search for Certification and Preparation. Next, we verified data across multiple sources, including prior works and state documents. Finally, we validated the dataset by contacting state education officials in all 51 jurisdictions. State feedback was used to confirm and refine the data, thereby improving accuracy.

Our data collection and verification took place between October 2023 and August 2025. The validation continued until early 2026.

Results 
Our work produces two outcomes: (1) the CSEP dataset and (2) refined procedures for data collection, verification, and validation.

For each policy, we included an indicator of whether a state has adopted the policy (yes/no), the adoption, and implementation school year. Overall, the data describe adoption and implementation patterns across policies over time, highlighting timing variation. The detailed, state-by-policy observations provide variation in the adoption and implementation of these policies across states.

As we refined our procedures, we produced a policy rubric that operationalizes the adoption and implementation school years for each policy. This served as a guide for our work as well as can support applications of the CSEP data and future policy data collection endeavors.

Significance 
This work extends both the scope and historical depth of prior documentation of CS education policies and aligns with the 2026 APPAM theme, “Fifty States, Fifty Systems: State Policy Variations and Impacts,” by providing a longitudinal dataset that captures variation in CS education policy adoption and implementation for all 50 states and D.C.

Our dataset supports applications for examining the adoption and implementation of CS education policies, such as analyses of policy diffusion, and for evaluating their effects on educational and workforce outcomes, including policy effects across contexts.

Beyond applications, the procedures we developed can serve as a guide for systematic data collection. By integrating legislative and regulatory policies and their timing (adoption and implementation), our approach provides practical guidance for documenting policy information across governance bodies and policy levers, thereby informing future primary data collection efforts in education and beyond.

Authors