Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Income Instability and the Response of the 2021 Expanded CTC

Friday, November 6, 10:15 to 11:45am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Salon I

Abstract

Does the 2021 monthly Child Tax Credit (CTC) offer working families relief from intrayear income shocks? Although recent studies have examined the 2021 CTC's effects on household poverty, hardship, and consumption, further research is needed to understand whether this policy has helped or hindered households experiencing month-to-month income instability. We employ quasi-experimental research designs and use nationally representative longitudinal data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation to test whether and how the nearly-universal 2021 CTC buffers against month-to-month income variability.

We find that the expanded CTC reduced the likelihood of a family experiencing a substantial income decline from one month to the next and significantly increased additional consecutive months with stable income within the year. The intent-to-treat effect was roughly 3.7 percentage points lower in negative income shock for households with children relative to their childless peers after the policy reform. Simply put, the monthly CTC decreased the incidence of substantial income drop among households with children by about 20 percent (relative to the pre-treatment mean of 17.1 percent). Monthly payments also reduced overall month-to-month income variability, as measured by the arc percent change, by approximately 16 percent. The treatment intensity estimates reveal that a $100 increase in the monthly payment is associated with a 2.4 percent decline in negative income shock among households with children. We also find a significant reduction in the number of months with volatile income as a function of the CTC.

While the instability reduction from the 2021 CTC is observed broadly across the income distribution and occupational groups, very low-income households and those employed in service occupations exhibit some of the largest subgroup-specific point estimate reductions. The findings highlight the importance of policy design regarding delivery timing to effectively address frequent income instability.

Authors