Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Background
High-quality pre-kindergarten (pre-K) can promote positive academic and social-emotional development (Phillips et al., 2017). Most states have publicly-funded pre-K programs, though they vary in their scale, spending per child (SPC), and program policies. Scale can limit the number of children receiving potential benefits, while SPC and program policies can shape quality, and therefore the likelihood that children benefit from pre-K (Zaslow et al., 2016). Given that children’s experiences, and therefore their academic and social-emotional outcomes, are shaped by the design of these programs, understanding state approaches to pre-K is key to understanding how they may or may not benefit from attending public pre-K.
Research question
How do states vary in their approaches to state pre-K, including program scale as measured by enrollment, spending per child, and the National Institute for Early Education Research’s (NIEER) quality benchmarks?
Data
We used data from the 2025 State of Preschool Yearbook, which compiles information from a survey of policymakers in all 50 states and territories including enrollment, spending, and program characteristics. The proportion of 4-year-olds in the state enrolled was calculated by dividing enrollment by Census estimates of the 4-year-old population. SPC was calculated by dividing total spending by the number of children enrolled. NIEER uses 10 evidence-based benchmarks to evaluate program quality, such as class size and teacher education/training.
Methods
We conducted a k-means cluster analysis of 66 state pre-K programs based on the proportion of 4-year-olds enrolled, SPC, and the proportion of quality benchmarks met. We used Gower’s distance, appropriate for mixed variable types, to determine our four clusters, though future work will explore variations in the number of clusters.
Results
Average pre-K enrollment was 24%, the average SPC was $9,944, and programs met an average of 6.5 benchmarks. Programs fell into four distinct clusters: high enrollment, medium-low spending, lowest quality (cluster 1); high enrollment, high spending, high quality (cluster 2); low enrollment, high spending, highest quality (cluster 3); and low enrollment, medium-low spending and quality (cluster 4). Cluster 1 (n=7) had an average enrollment of 62%, average SPC of $9,134, and met an average of 3.3 benchmarks. Cluster 2 (n=17) had an average enrollment of 46%, average SPC of $11,705, and averaged 8.0 benchmarks. Cluster 3 (n=17) had an average enrollment of 13%, average SPC of $10,527, and averaged 8.9 benchmarks. Cluster 4 (n=25) had an average enrollment of 8%, average SPC of $8,623, and averaged 4.6 benchmarks.
Implications
This study furthers our understanding of the variation in state approaches to public pre-K and the nuanced relationship between public pre-K and child outcomes. Given finite resources, some states seemingly prioritized scale over quality, others prioritized quality, and some prioritized both or neither. A large-scale, low-quality program may not improve children’s outcomes, while a small-scale, high-quality program may only improve outcomes for a small number of children. Balancing scale and quality during pre-K expansion is key to ensuring that children receive the full benefits of high-quality pre-K.