Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Stabilizing Child Care Businesses: Provider Perspectives on DC’s Early Educator Compensation Program

Friday, November 6, 1:45 to 3:15pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Salon B

Abstract

Across the country, early childhood educators are consistently paid low wages, driving high rates of turnover in the field (McLean et al. 2024). In turn, child care providers must navigate cycles of vacancies and hiring alongside rising costs and slim margins, resulting in higher tuition prices or turning away families seeking care (Bassok and Weisner 2023; Department of Treasury 2021).

To address drivers of turnover and alleviate cost constraints, the District of Columbia launched the Early Childhood Educator Pay Equity Fund (PEF). The PEF is a voluntary program through which participating providers receive funding to offer competitive wages according to a minimum salary schedule accounting for educators’ roles and credentials. It aims to help providers increase salaries without passing on costs to families through tuition increases. This study investigates whether the PEF supports the recruitment and retention of educators, promotes high-quality caregiving, and stabilizes providers’ finances while minimizing financial impacts on families.

We conducted a survey that reached 96 directors or operators of 112 licensed DC child care providers participating in the PEF (31% response rate). We analyzed measures of the perceived impact of the PEF on recruitment and retention, workforce qualifications and well-being, tuition changes, and financial stability. We used sampling weights to calculate descriptive statistics for the full survey sample that generalize to all DC-licensed child care providers. We also tested for differences between center- and home-based providers and across subsidy program participation status, as the PEF funding formula allocates different amounts based on these characteristics. We supplemented and contextualized these findings with responses to open-ended questions about the impact of the PEF.

Preliminary findings indicate that providers perceived the PEF as supporting their financial well-being, with more support among providers accepting subsidies and home-based providers. Most respondents agreed that the PEF made it easier to recruit (60 percent) and retain (63 percent) qualified educators and allowed them to compensate staff fairly (59 percent). Additionally, respondents reported that their participation in the PEF substantially benefited educators’ ability (53 percent) and motivation (58 percent) to pursue additional education or professional development. Although most surveyed providers reported no increases in tuition in the past year, among the 39 percent that did increase tuition, almost three-quarters of them attributed this change to PEF funding falling short of what is needed to pay educators’ higher salaries, at least in part. Almost half of surveyed providers reported that without the PEF, they would have to increase tuition.

These findings build on past evidence that indicates the PEF is helping to stabilize DC’s early educator workforce, increase compensation, and incentivize educators’ pursuit of additional learning opportunities. Additionally, they suggest that by providing sufficient funding to raise compensation for the early childhood workforce, child care providers will experience greater financial stability and can minimize the cost burden to families while maintaining quality. As policymakers consider how to address turnover and instability in the child care field, this evidence points to the importance of educator wage supports for helping educators, providers, and the children they serve.

Authors