Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Early childhood education (ECE) has emerged as a central focus of public investment, with federal and state resources increasingly channeled toward supply-side interventions intended to expand capacity, improve quality, and strengthen the workforce. Yet persistent staff turnover threatens to erode the returns to these investments in ways that existing administrative and survey data struggle to capture. This paper asks how turnover shapes the effectiveness of supply-side ECE initiatives and through what mechanisms it does so.
We draw on over 100 semi-structured interviews with childcare providers, apprentices, and program administrators across three Texas-based initiatives: registered apprenticeships, shared services alliances, and pre-K partnerships. Interviews were conducted with participants at grant-receiving colleges and organizations. We analyze the data using thematic coding and cross-case comparison across the three program types, allowing us to identify patterns that recur—and, in some cases, surface most sharply within a single program type—despite differences in program design, target population, and implementation context.
We document three mutually reinforcing mechanisms through which turnover disrupts these initiatives. First, economic competition with higher-paying sectors continually draws workers away from ECE, where wages remain compressed relative to jobs requiring comparable or lower skill. Providers and apprentices name turnover as a defining difficulty of the industry, but providers operating within current funding structures lack the capacity to raise wages to competitive levels. Second, the operational costs of turnover divert organizational resources away from core educational activities and day-to-day business operations toward continuous cycles of recruitment, onboarding, and training—absorbing precisely the capacity that these initiatives are designed to free up. Third, we identify a "training paradox": investments in worker credentials raise marketability without generating commensurate wage gains within ECE, effectively subsidizing workers' transitions into better-paying jobs and sectors rather than stabilizing the workforce these programs aim to support. Taken together, these findings reframe how policymakers should understand the returns to public investment in ECE. We document turnover as a structural feature of ECE markets that policymakers must reckon with when designing interventions intended to meaningfully support providers and the workforce.