Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Poster #37 - Policy Ambiguity and Preschool Inclusion: A 50-State Study

Friday, November 6, 5:00 to 6:30pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Grand Ballroom

Abstract

Although decades of research have documented the benefits of inclusive early childhood education, most preschoolers with disabilities in the United States are still not served in regular early education settings. Nationally, only about 41% of preschoolers served under IDEA Part B, Section 619 receive services in regular education settings for most of the school day, leaving nearly 60% outside inclusive environments. This persistent gap is concerning because inclusive preschool has been associated with stronger social, language, and communication outcomes for young children with disabilities, particularly when classroom quality and peer interactions are strong. Yet rates of preschool inclusion have remained at or below about 50% for decades. One possible explanation is that states vary substantially in the clarity and strength of policies intended to support inclusion.

This study examined the extent to which stronger state policies supporting inclusion for preschoolers with disabilities are associated with higher rates of preschool inclusion. It addressed two questions: (1) Are there states with strong policies in place to support inclusion for preschoolers with disabilities? and (2) Is there a relationship between the strength of those policies and states’ actual rates of inclusion?

The study used a quantitative cross-sectional design including all 50 states and the District of Columbia. Data came from state websites and publicly available policy and guidance documents, which were coded using six criteria derived from the DEC/NAEYC framework for early childhood inclusion: high-quality programs, mixed-delivery settings, high expectations for children, access, participation, and supports. Based on this coding, states were classified into overall policy-strength categories of missing, weak, emerging, or strong. The outcome variable was each state’s preschool inclusion rate for 2023–24. Head Start enrollment, child poverty, and racial composition were included as control variables.

Methods combined document analysis and policy coding with ordinary least squares regression. The study was informed by Bronfenbrenner’s ecological systems theory, which highlights how state-level conditions shape local practice, and Matland’s ambiguity-conflict model, which suggests that policy clarity may influence implementation.

Findings revealed a clear descriptive pattern: states with stronger inclusion policies tended to have higher rates of preschool inclusion. Policy environments were fairly evenly distributed across categories, and mean inclusion increased from 32.9% in states with no explicit preschool inclusion policy to 48.2% in states with strong policies. Regression results showed that each one-unit increase in policy strength was associated with an estimated 5.5 percentage point increase in inclusion, controlling for Head Start enrollment, poverty, and racial composition.

These findings suggest that stronger state policy may be an important lever for increasing preschool inclusion, though policy strength alone does not fully explain cross-state variation. The results underscore the need for a clearer national definition of preschool inclusion, stronger state implementation expectations, and better infrastructure to support inclusive practice across settings.

Author