Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Definitions Matter: Are There Enough Good Jobs for Credential Holders Without a Four-Year Degree?

Friday, November 6, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 1st Floor/Lobby Level, Room: Boylston

Abstract

Background: States have committed at least $8.1 billion to sub-baccalaureate initiatives, and Workforce Pell covers short-term programs. These investments rely on alignment measures that often omit living-wage standards and differ in which institutions they count.

Research Questions: This paper addresses: (1) To what extent are state sub-baccalaureate educational systems aligned with high-quality, in-demand (HQID) occupations? (2) How do wage standards and institutional coverage change measured alignment? (3) How do results vary across occupations and states?

Methods: Our 2015 to 2023 panel of 51 jurisdictions links IPEDS completions, OEWS wages, state occupational projections, and MIT Living Wage estimates for 99 sub-baccalaureate occupations. Seven HQID definitions combine demand criteria with single-adult or family living wages. Fractional and potential models bound program-to-occupation allocation. Alignment rates divide HQID-allocated awards by awards from programs linked to these occupations; supply-to-demand (S/D) ratios divide them by projected openings.

Findings: In 2023, fractional allocation assigns 59.5% of linked-program awards to in-demand occupations. Requiring a single-adult living wage lowers this to 31.4%, and a family living wage to 21.2%. National S/D ratios stay below 1 under every definition. Truck drivers and nursing assistants account for nearly a third of target openings. State rankings shift with the definition. Counting for-profit and less-than-two-year institutions raises alignment with in-demand occupations but lowers family-wage alignment.

Implications: Because hiring needs and wage adequacy are distinct goals, alignment assessments are not policy-neutral. State agencies should report hiring and wage standards together and specify which providers they count before using these measures to guide investment.

Authors