Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Effects of Child Welfare Policy Reform on Family for Children with Disabilities

Friday, November 6, 10:15 to 11:45am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Salon H

Abstract

Background: The 2018 Family First Prevention Services Act (FFPSA) marked a major shift in child welfare financing by redirecting funds toward evidence-based prevention, with the goal of reducing foster care entry. States adopted the legislation at different times, with some enacting local legislation in tandem, creating heterogenous policy reform across the country. While some studies suggest that foster care entry and placement are declining following policy implementation, this aggregate trend obscures its effect on child subgroups. This is an important gap because children with disabilities face greater risks foster care involvement and reduced permanency placement than their peers. To address this limitation, this study examines the effects of FFPSA on foster care entry and permanency placements, isolating effects for children with disabilities.

Methods: I used Child Welfare Outcomes Reports from 2019-2025 that includes 260 state-year observations collected from AFCARS and NCANDS. This data was paired with year of Title IV-E approval obtained from the National Conference of State Legislatures. Using the calendar year after approval as the implementation year, I estimated the causal effect of FFPSA on foster care entry and permanency placements using difference-in-differences modeling and event studies. My analysis involved evaluating the full sample of all children as a baseline, then separating out models for foster care entry rates and children with disabilities.

Results: FFPSA implementation was not statistically associated with permanency placement or with entry rates across the population of children or children with disabilities. However, this becomes significant once 2020 is excluded resulting in a reduction of 256 placements for all children (p = 0.035). Pre-trend testing indicates that the parallel trends assumption holds for the full sample (p = 0.311) but fails for the separated models evaluating children with disabilities (p = 0.001) and entry rates (p = 0.001). For the full sample, event study estimates showed no significant differential before implementation for all children (p = 0.208), but permanency exits declined with a significant reduction one year after approval (p = 0.020) with larger but insignificant reductions in later years. In the comparison between states that had a Title IV-E plan and enacted local legislation, only a plan, or neither, the first group showed significant decline in permanency placements for children with disabilities one year after approval (p = 0.010). This group showed no evidence of differential trend pre-Title IV-E (0.767). All other comparisons including every model for states with plans only, showed significant pre-implementation differences (p from 0.001 to 0.035).

Conclusion: While baseline models suggest a null relationship, this study demonstrates that disruptions of Covid-19 in 2020 may mask the impact of the FFPSA the policy. Because baseline pre-trends failed for several models, the most robust causal evidence emerges from states combining federal plans with local legislation which was the only framework to pass pre-trend validation while successfully reducing permanency placements for children with disabilities. This finding may indicate that efficacy of federal child welfare protections may rely on coordinated local legislative scaffolding when specific to vulnerable groups.

Author