Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Overcoming Institutional Barriers for Policy Execution: Comparative Data Sharing in Shanghai, Singapore, and Estonia

Friday, November 6, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Boston University

Abstract

In the contemporary landscape of public administration, cross-departmental data sharing serves as the critical infrastructure for executing complex public policies and mitigating administrative burdens. However, as governments implement ambitious digital governance policies, they frequently encounter profound structural resistance within their own bureaucracies.

These institutional barriers perpetuate policy fragmentation and siloed public services. Drawing upon Structurational Model of Technology, this study conceptualizes technology adoption not merely as a technical upgrade, but as a disruptive institutional innovation policy that continuously interacts with and reshapes traditional bureaucratic structures. This research aims to unpack the "black box" of policy implementation by exploring how varying state systems overcome internal resistance to achieve robust data interoperability. We propose a "Technology Adoption - Organizational Structure" interaction framework, focusing on how two critical variables—data governance architectures and internal sharing motivations—drive organizational change. Supported by extensive international fieldwork, we employ a comparative multi-case analysis of three global digital frontrunners representing distinct policy ecosystems: Shanghai (integrated governance), Singapore (polycentric governance), and Estonia (distributed governance). The study involved in-depth interviews with over 20 key stakeholders, including the Director of Data Governance at the Shanghai Big Data Center, a former Minister of Communications and Information of Singapore, and digital strategy advisors to the Government of Estonia. 

Our findings reveal that while the structural resistance and institutional environments vary significantly across the three regions, a strategic alignment of centralized data governance and strong internal motivation acts as a universal catalyst for structural adaptation. However, the exact evolutionary pathways and specific policy capacities diverge profoundly based on the system's unique tensions. In Shanghai, performance-driven metrics combined with integrated governance facilitated an "incremental change" against strong structural resistance, excelling in rapid, cross-domain data collision for comprehensive policy execution. Singapore, utilizing pragmatic, value-driven motivations within a polycentric architecture, underwent a "steady change," optimizing high-quality domain data to empower highly targeted public service delivery. Conversely, Estonia, driven by a national political vision within a distributed architecture, achieved a "revolutionary change" against weak resistance, perfectly balancing highly efficient interoperability with robust public trust and societal data security. 

Ultimately, this study demonstrates that overcoming data silos is fundamentally an institutional reform challenge rather than a purely technological one. By customizing the micro-level combination of governance structures and sharing motivations to their specific institutional tensions, governments can successfully dismantle bureaucratic silos. These findings provide a vital theoretical and practical roadmap for regional and national governments striving to optimize state capacity and enhance integrated policy outcomes.

Keywords: Cross-Departmental Data Sharing; Digital Governance Policy; Policy Execution; Policy Outcomes.

Author