Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Analyzing Budget Mechanisms as a Method for States to Plan for Disasters

Friday, November 6, 10:15 to 11:45am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Boston University

Abstract

When dealing with disasters, states have a variety of mechanisms that they can use. Most disaster events and how a state can respond are foreseeable given a state’s geography, previous experience, and available resources. However, there are also anticipated unknowns when dealing with disasters such as catastrophic events, atypical disaster events, and general unknowns such as cost estimation and revenue disruption. (Redburn, 2021). Generally, states have two avenues for budgeting for these unknowns: 1) typical disasters and 2) unknown disruptions. One example of an unknown disruption is the Covid-19 pandemic. While a pandemic was foreseeable beforehand, the exact extent of its disruption was not known. How then do states budget for disasters? What mechanisms do they use to smooth disruptions from disaster events? Common state budget mechanisms include appropriations, budget stabilization funds, reserves, and tax options. This paper analyzes budget mechanisms, creating categories of similar mechanisms which follow various budget theories to identify what steps states can take to make their budgeting systems more resilient to disaster impacts. The Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) methodology is used to look at these mechanisms within an overall set of available options for states, rather than as individual determinants. When looking at fiscal health for states, the ones that are the most stable are those with budgeted disaster-specific mechanisms, executive control over the budget, professional budget offices, and performance management systems which incorporate feedback. By looking at mechanisms within overall sets of available options, this paper focuses on the overall picture of a state’s budget and fiscal health, rather than simply the effectiveness of individual mechanisms which are never used in a vacuum. Findings indicates that while disasters are a ubiquitous problem, there are specific sets of mechanisms that states can utilize in order to build-in reliability for unknown situations and smooth the disruptive fiscal effects of disasters.

Author