Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Funding Public Schools in Maryland: Determining a Poverty Concentration-Based Threshold

Saturday, November 7, 1:45 to 3:15pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: MIT

Abstract

Causal evidence shows that increased school spending leads to improved student outcomes into adulthood, with more pronounced effects for students from low-income backgrounds (Jackson et al., 2016; Lafortune et al., 2018). However, Title I, Part A of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, the largest federal funding source for high-poverty districts, is insufficient for meeting the needs of students and schools (Walsh, 2025). The most common state supplement to federal funding is the foundation formula, which sets a minimum per-pupil adequacy foundation funding amount. Also common is the addition of weighted student funds, where extra funding is provided for students in need, including disadvantaged students. Weighted student funding acknowledges the higher costs of educating certain student subgroups and directs additional resources to offset systemic inequities.

In 2019, recognizing the problem of rising concentrated disadvantage in the state, Maryland lawmakers were considering adding categorical aid that would supplement foundation and weighted funding by directing additional resources based on concentrated disadvantage. Our initial analyses showed the relationship between concentrated disadvantage and outcomes using a linear estimator (Henneberger et al., 2023). However, policymakers needed to know whether there was a threshold at which the relationship changed because they needed a cut-point for their concentration-based formula (i.e., the level of school concentrated disadvantage at which the proposed extra funding would begin). 

We used multiple membership multilevel modeling (Beretvas, 2011) to nest members of our statewide cohort of students in 6th grade in 2008 (N=54,465) in all middle and high schools attended. We modeled the likelihood of each academic outcome, with dummy variables for all concentration deciles except for Decile 1, and tested whether each decile’s coefficient was statistically significantly different from the coefficient for the preceding decile. Models controlled for student and school characteristics. 

The relationship of concentrated disadvantage with outcomes generally worsened as concentrated disadvantage increased at the lower deciles, but not at the higher deciles; for example, for on-time high school graduation, the coefficient for the 3rd decile (-2.27) was significantly lower than the coefficient for the 2nd decile (-1.38), but the coefficient for the 8th decile (-3.24) was not statistically different from the coefficient for the 7th decile (-3.22). This pattern varied depending on outcome: for dropout the relationship stopped worsening after the 3rd decile, and for college enrollment after the 4th decile.

Lawmakers used these findings to establish a concentration of poverty school grant program, enacted through the Blueprint for Maryland’s Future legislation (Chs. 36 & 37, Acts of 2021; codified at Md. Code Ann., Educ. §§ 5-213, 5-223). Two complementary funding streams are provided when schools meet the threshold for concentrated poverty (initially 80% but lowering to 55% by 2027). First, the personnel grant provides funds for dedicated community school coordinators and full-time licensed health care practitioners. Second, a per-pupil grant provides funds for wraparound services and other programs identified through the schools’ needs assessments and improvement planning processes. A discussion will focus on how our results were translated into policy changes.

Authors