Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Spillover Effects of Million Dollar Projects on Wage Distribution and Skill Demand

Saturday, November 7, 1:45 to 3:15pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 1st Floor/Lobby Level, Room: Tremont

Abstract

Not all labor markets are created equal, some have higher unemployment rate than others and there is no one size fit all solution to this geographical inequality. But one answer that many localities have reached is to attract and retain large employers like IBM or Amazon. This is a strategy endorsed by the federal government such that local and state governments spend $47 billion annually trying to attract and retain large firms. Large firms get this money in the name of economic development as governments hope to harvest the seed of agglomeration externalities in the form of indirect job creation. The story is that tire and electric cord firms will set up shop near a newly subsidized automobile factory. But are these mega projects really worth their subsidy price tag? What are the true spillover–agglomeration–effects of large firm entry on local labor markets?

In this paper, we study the effect of large million dollar projects entry on local labor market dynamics in terms of overall employment, wage distribution and skill demand. To get at this question, we use two datasets. First, we use real estate magazines and internet searches to construct a dataset of million-dollar projects’ opening date and location where runner-up sites are known. Second, we use online job ads in Lightcast vacancy data for our outcomes of interest. We then match the winner and runner-up county pair to corresponding online job ads in Lightcast data and use a difference-in-difference research design. Our research method compares counties that successfully bid for a million dollar project, with counties that bid and lost that project.

We find that, on average, a million-dollar project entry significantly shifts the hourly wage and annual salaries distributions downward and have a negative albeit insignificant effect on firms and posting growth. It also reduced minimum education requirement listed but doesn't change years of experience listed on job ads. On the extensive margin front, million-dollar-projects' entry has no effect on demand for cognitive, computer, social and management skills. Since the entry of MDP improves the prospects of workers without a college degree, policymakers should condition subsidies to large firms on the type of jobs they directly create.

Author