Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Poster #88 - From Lawsuits to Lost Funds: Preemption of Local Governments' Homelessness Responses

Saturday, November 7, 12:00 to 1:30pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Grand Ballroom - Salon EFG

Abstract

State preemption, or the restriction of local powers due to overriding state law, is an increasingly prominent feature of urban policymaking. One policy area where preemption is especially noticeable is municipal responses to homelessness. For example, in Florida (a state with broad preemption), counties and municipalities are barred from “authorizing or otherwise allowing public camping or sleeping on public property.” While literature across disciplines has focused on the role of the public sector in responding to homelessness via sheltering/access to housing, policing, and health assistance, little to no work has developed a comprehensive investigation of local governments’ ability to respond to the issue given state-level legislation. To assess the national landscape of these responses, I use publicly available state statutes to construct a typology that categorizes all 50 states by their scope of homelessness-related preemption, focusing on the domain of public camping/sleeping. Additionally, to better grasp the dynamics of homelessness responses across areas, I utilize three case studies that illustrate the partisanship and rationales behind such policies, as well as details on implementation. States’ preemption approaches (ranging from civil liability to home rule) provide useful variation, as does recent policy diffusion. In total, this work allows academics and practitioners alike to become familiar with the policy landscapes that result from intergovernmental constraints on an important issue. It also sets up further research on local homelessness governance and the possibility of policy substitution into punitive approaches, such as “hostile architecture” given greater universal local control of procurement.

Author