Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
One of the underappreciated characteristics of contemporary American party politics is the emergence of a historically unprecedented generation gap between the mass coalitions of the Democrats and Republicans. As I noted in an analysis published by the Monkey Cage blog on December 10 (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/12/10/an-under-appreciated-fact-about-the-2016-election-the-massive-generation-gap), the difference by age in partisan vote choice in the 2016 election was larger than in any election in the modern era—with the exception of the 2008 and 2012 elections, which similarly produced massive gaps between the preferences of younger and older voters. The results in 2016 confirm that this phenomenon is not merely a function of Barack Obama’s personal popularity with millennial-generation citizens, but reflects a more enduring social divide.
This paper explores the foundations of this new generation gap and considers its implications for party politics in the current political climate. Drawing upon survey data, election results, and other data sources, I address several plausible explanations for the presence of this generation gap:
1. Demographic: younger Americans are more ethnically diverse than older Americans, and ethnic identity has become more strongly associated with partisanship in recent years;
2. Economic: younger Americans are less prosperous than older Americans, and economic interests are historically a strong predictor of party identification;
3. Socialization: younger Americans were socialized during the presidencies of Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama, which attracted them to the Democratic Party (or repelled them from the Republican Party) due to the relative performance of these individual party leaders;
4. Cultural: younger Americans are more culturally progressive than older Americans, while the partisan salience of cultural views has risen significantly over the past two decades.
Based on the evidence compiled so far, this analysis is likely to find that the cultural explanation is particularly important in accounting for the contemporary partisan generation gap. Younger Americans collectively hold left-leaning views on social and racial issues that attract them to Democratic candidates, while the more culturally conservative older generation has become increasingly at home in the Republican Party.
The salience of these issues has increased due to the progression of significant social and cultural change in the U.S. over the past few decades—change that has been welcomed much more by Democratic politicians than by Republicans. As this paper demonstrates, Democratic leaders have become much more willing to publicly support socially liberal positions, losing much of their prior political defensiveness on such matters, and have prioritized overt rhetorical appeals to younger voters. Republican politicians, in contrast, have increasingly abandoned the future-oriented optimistic themes associated with Ronald Reagan in favor of nostalgic invocations of America’s past and warnings that social change is a threat to the country’s future. Amplified by conservative media sources that overwhelmingly appeal to, and draw audiences of, older Americans, these divergent partisan messages have helped to produce the generation gap now in evidence in American elections.
In closing, I consider the consequences of the generation gap for the near future of American politics. The ascension of Donald Trump to the presidency is likely to further harden this gap, given the dramatic difference in Trump’s popularity among older and younger citizens. While the pro-Democratic tilt of the millennial generation is often portrayed as one of the party’s most valuable assets, the lower rates of voter turnout and participation among younger citizens limit the power of this advantage for Democratic candidates—especially in non-presidential years. In addition, the pro-Republican leanings of middle-aged white Americans provides the GOP with an advantage in candidate recruitment and campaign finance, while the aging of the populous baby boom generation limits the extent to which Democrats benefit from newer generations’ coming of age. While the contemporary generation gap has considerable influence on American politics, therefore, its does not bestow a consistent advantage on either partisan side.