The Black Market Blues: The Political Costs of Illicit Currency Markets

• In Event: Economic and Political Performance in Developing Democracies

Abstract

Countries with high inflation and stringent currency regulations frequently have thriving black markets for dollars. We argue that the black market for dollars has important political consequences: it hurts the pocketbooks of many citizens, and therefore reduces support for the government. Evidence from Argentina supports this argument. Using aggregate time-series data, we estimate that a ten percent increase in the black market price of the dollar relative to the official price reduces Presidential approval by 5 percentage points in the long run. To test the pocketbook mechanism more directly, we use individual-level data from a list experiment. We find that people that bought dollars on the black market were 10 percentage points less likely to vote for the incumbent party in the 2015 Presidential election. These findings suggest that the black market for dollars can have important political consequences.

Authors

• Luis Schiumerini, University of Notre Dame

• David A. Steinberg, Johns Hopkins University