Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Ethnic Composition, Legibility and War's Conditional Effect on Fiscal Capacity

Fri, October 1, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

\noindent There has been substantial debate on whether the argument that warfare enhances state capacity can be applied to contexts other than Western Europe. The argument in this paper is that the relationship between war and fiscal capacity is conditional on the ethnic composition and the resulting differences in the legibility of the population. More specifically, ethnic heterogeneity and ethnic dissimilarity should result in higher illegibility of the society to the state. Illegibility should make the returns from investment in fiscal capacity lower and consequently should hinder state's investment and increases in fiscal capacity during wartime. Hence, wartime increases in fiscal capacity should be higher in localities with ethnically homogeneous and ethnically similar populations. These expectations are tested and confirmed with an original local-level fiscal revenue dataset in the late Ottoman Empire. Additional analyses with local-level data confirm the arguments regarding the mechanisms through illegibility and the cost of investment, suggesting that low ethnic similarity and high ethnic heterogeneity render populations less legible and increase the necessary cost of investment for building fiscal capacity. Finally, an analysis of the correspondences between the center and the bureaucrats in the field reveal the difficulties they experienced due to language barriers and the resulting illegibility. Overall, the results indicate that one reason why the war-makes-states argument may be less likely to work outside of Western Europe can be the differences in ethnic composition.

Author