Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Imposition of Race-based Policies in Colonial America

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Political scientists assume a race-divided American polity. Some political scientists and scholars of race and ethnicity assume the existence of a race-conscious society since 1619. And as the colonies and new nation grew in population, wealth, and size, so, too, did the importance and impact of slavery on colonial, state and national politics and government. Others point to inflection points in the racialization of American society, such as Bacon’s Rebellion in 1676 (Greene, Kendi) or the American Revolutionary (Fogleman, Roediger).

I argue that it took years of discriminatory colonial legislation to differentiate African and European unfree workers on the basis of race, to strip “Negroes” of their rights and protections (dismemberment was an acceptable punishment), and to criminalize sexual relations between races (except between male European-American masters and female African Americans).
The puzzle I address is how colonial society went from one not distinguished by race (Stampp, E. Morgan) to one of entrenched racism. I contribute to the existing literature by pointing out the incremental and cumulative effects of the policies initiated in the two most influential and oldest slave colonies, Virginia and Maryland. These initiatives distanced European Americans from African Americans in the late seventeenth century and early eighteenth and provoke hostility, whereas previously the populations had socialized and fraternized (E. Morgan, Roediger). That slaveowners and other propertied Americans were antagonistic to blacks—those they dominated and profited from—should not surprise; surprising is why subaltern European Americans acceded to and, in short order, helped protect slavery. As evidence, I rely on the collected laws of the Virginia and Maryland assemblies, on other primary sources (court records, correspondence, etc.), and on the rich secondary literature on Virginia, Maryland, and race in colonial America.

In order to explain how the political development of unfree European Americans, former servants, and their offspring coincided and contrasted with that of African Americans, causing this great shift, I adopt the work of Harrison White. White observes that society is composed of both categories of persons (who share one or more identified attributes) and networks (those with whom people have direct or indirect interpersonal bonds). The “web of categories which organize cognitively the world” forms an intersubjective reality that, in turn, influences peoples’ behavior (although categories may conflict with each other, and not neatly map on to interpersonal networks). Attending to both cultural and relational aspects of role-related behaviors provides me with leverage for understanding of societal structure and the “culture” of the cognitive categories of meaning systems, value systems, familiar types, and “frames” (the higher-order, often taken-for-granted concepts that span and incorporate the intersubjective categories and the practical, workaday networks).

I determine the “categories” by which unfree and poor European Americans saw themselves by studying the little correspondence and few memoirs that remain of this typically illiterate population, the writings of masters (e.g., Landon Carter, George Washington) and others who comment on the white poor, and the terms used by colonial censuses and surveys to describe inhabitants. I determine the interpersonal networks both within and across races by also studying correspondence, memoirs, masters’ accounts, and court documents. I also rely on thousands of newspaper advertisements for runaway servants (which I have in a database), because the ads list with whom the bonded servants ran away (e.g., other servants, slaves, children), stated possible destinations, and listed the servants’ personal qualities.

In sum—and, admittedly, this is to oversimplify—the frames by which colonists viewed the “lower sort” of European Americans and African Americans evolved from one of shared economic and social status on the bottom rung of colonial society to one of distinct races and pervaded by racism. This paper explains how the establishment of slavery and a subsequent slave society was a gradual, top-down imposition by colonial leaders and was neither an “unthinking decision” nor an inevitable development.

This paper reflects part of a book project on how the presence of two-hundred-and-fifty thousand unfree Europeans (i.e., indentured servants, exiled convicts, abductees, political prisoners, and others) impacted the politics and culture of the Founding, where these subaltern European Americans also impinged on the lives of the framers, affected the texts of the founding documents, and influenced American political culture.

Author