Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Role of Pluralism and Polarization in Discussions About Unemployment

Thu, September 30, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The role of pluralism and polarization in discussions about unemployment during the COVID-19 pandemic

There is evidence that the current information environment, with the ever-growing use of social media platforms, is having a negative impact on democratic institutions and principles. One key problem is that often citizens are either uninformed or misinformed or select information to reinforce their existing beliefs. The problem relates to the relativism of our times, within the information environment diverse interpretations of facts have similar value and tend to replace previous overarching narratives about reality (Salgado 2018). While pluralism and diversity of perspectives are valuable components of democracy, they are only of value if sufficient numbers consume a range of perspectives and analyse them critically. At present it appears that there is a greater tendency for interpretive, biased and emotional logics to prevail over facts (e.g., O’Connor and Weatherall 2020). Hence, we must reflect on the importance of pluralism and diversity as an indisputable strength of democratic performance. This state of affairs is not just limited to partisan or ideological routes to meeting the outcomes desired by the electorate. The contestation of science and discrediting of experts has become all too common across social media platforms (Tran et al. 2020). Arguably this phenomenon has proved most dangerous within the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. In the context of the current pandemic the circulation of alternative perspectives gives these particular relevance and means that they could impact on the individual’s willingness to follow the health authorities’ and government’s instructions, particularly when economic conditions and subsistence enter into the equation. As we have seen in a number of countries such justifications have been feeding popular protests against lockdown and social distancing measures (Lilleker et al. 2021).

The problem is not only has the pandemic seen an accompanying ‘infodemic’, with misinformation circulating from spurious sources online. Populist political leaders have publicly challenged scientists as well as the guidance released by the WHO and dismissed evidence for restricting freedoms. The difficulty in weighing what should take priority, the economy or public health, has been a major concern for all governments and has caused social and political tensions in many countries. Our paper seeks to explore what impact this has had on public discourse and if polarized positions at a governmental and political level permeate public self-expression online. We look in particular at how this relates to discussions surrounding unemployment and how the restrictive measures put forward to tackle the pandemic crisis affected the economy and people’s jobs and in turn how this shaped responses to measures put in place to limit the spread of COVID-19.

Using a dataset of posts and responses on Twitter and Reddit, collected from January to July 2020 (total sample of 832856 tweets and 2989 Reddit posts), we compare public discourse across four nations. Two of the cases are nations where the leaders played down the severity of the virus and challenged their own scientists and health advisors: Brazil and the USA. We compare these to two cases where voices which challenged the need for lockdowns and face mask wearing were marginalized voices and the pandemic crisis was less politicized and less polarized: Portugal and the UK. Using content analysis, the dataset of unique entries will be coded for the presence/absence of expressions of dissonance and antagonism as proxy measures of polarization. Polarization’s polymorphisms will then be analysed qualitatively for their implicit and explicit meanings (e.g., terminology) in order to further understand the different interpretations of facts and how reactions are expressed. We will also measure the diversity of positions in the messages circulating about these topics and perform a network analysis to check the sources of specific claims. The research will thus contribute to determining the extent to which public discourse is shaped by the tone, position and terminology employed by partisan or national leaders operating in the political sphere of a nation and the extent a polarized politics results in a polarized public sphere.

Authors