Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Political theorists must pluralize the discipline if they wish to make timely contributions to global political debates. A few decades ago, political theorists in US graduate programs studied mostly European and American political thinkers with a few scholars specializing in Chinese or Islamic political thought. Now, political theorists realzie that they all must read, teach, and research a wide array of authors, books, traditions, conventions, and so forth, to comment intelligently and ethically about political affairs.
One challenge facing Euro-American political theorists, however, is how to make sense of foreign traditions. Canonical figures in the academic field of political theory such as Leo Strauss, Hannah Arendt, and Martha Nussbaum have taught us how to read the ancient Greeks and apply their insights to the present. But how can Euro-American political theorists engage other traditions in ways that both respect their difference and want the channels of communication to flow in both directions?
In this essay, I propose a method for constructing conversations about politics across traditions and illustrate it by showing how Han Feizi and Machiavelli articulate conceptions of realism that overlap in some ways and differ in others.
The method that I propose in this project is to ask the same questions to different authors, analyze the answers, and then compare the answers. In this way, we fashion a kind of Socratic dialogue in our own minds with political thinkers spanning time and place but still addressing perennial concerns. The questions I propose to ask about political thinkers include:
• What is their biography?
• What real world problems were they addressing?
• What philosophical problems were they addressing?
• What is their view of human nature?
• What principles do they think should govern politics?
• How do they justify their views?
• What do we think?
In this essay, I will then show how this method enables us to fabricate a conversation between Han Feizi, the Chinese Legalist whose advice appeared to help the Qin Emperor unify China, and Niccolò Machiavelli, the founder of modern Western realism who envisioned a unified Italy. Han Feizi and Machiavelli were both ministers trying to get the ears of rulers, were concerned about political fragmentation, criticized idealists who wanted politics to follow Confucian or Christian morality, believed human beings to be fundamentally acquisitive, offered advice to rulers about how to acquire and maintain power, justified their views by appealing to the historical record, and prompt readers to wonder if politics should follow the same rules as the rest of life.
In short, I hope that this paper shares ideas about how to pluralize the academic discipline of political theory while also advancing the conversation about political realism. The paper engages the secondary literature on Han Feizi, Machiavelli, and political realism by Tongdong Bai, Daniel Bell, Owen Flanagan, Alison McQueen, Peter R. Moody, Jr., Enzo Rossi, Brian W. Van Norden, Leo Strauss, and Yves Winter.