Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Centrality of Ethnicity and Religion in Stereotypes About Immigrants

Thu, September 30, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Recent evidence suggests that citizens of industrial democracies tend to agree on the desired attributes of potential immigrants. Across the political spectrum and levels of education, voters prefer the newcomers to have valuable skills, learn the language, and commit to legal entry. Despite this “hidden consensus,” however, political conflict around immigration in the United States and Western Europe persists---if not intensifies. What is the reason for this apparent contradiction? I suggest that the answer to this question is to be found in natives’ beliefs about “who the immigrants are.” Voters diverge in their perceptions about attributes of actual immigrants---and this impact their opinions about immigration. To test this hypothesis, I design a novel unobtrusive method to measure respondents’ beliefs (or stereotypes) about immigrant populations based on the conjoint experiment. It allows assessing multiple dimensions of stereotypes (for instance, ethnicity and skill) simultaneously and is robust with respect to the concerns of social desirability and rationalization. Using this method, I implement two original survey studies in the United States and Britain respectively. I demonstrate that respondents’ stereotypes about immigrants are dominated by race/ethnicity and religion---not skills or economic contributions. I also show that beliefs about immigrants’ race/ethnicity and religion are stronger associate with respondents’ opinions on immigration than ones related to skill or dependence on welfare. Results of separate priming experiments embedded in surveys strongly suggest that stereotypes about immigrants are causally prior with respect to attitudes toward immigration. My findings highlight the importance of variation in mass stereotypes about immigrants---mostly ignored by researchers so far---for immigration policy opinions. They also show that experiments focusing on individual immigrants likely underestimate the importance of race/ethnicity and religion in politics of immigration. Methodologically, I present a new measure of stereotypes about policy target populations that can be used in political psychology and public opinion research.

Author