Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper reflects the results and insights gained from my ongoing PhD dissertation work under Prof. Jessica Pisano at the New School for Social Research. For this study, I immersed myself in Walmart and Target stores in a post-industrial region of upstate New York . I grew up in this area and worked at both Walmart and Target; many of my family and friends are still working in retail throughout the region. In addition to my own ethnographic profile, I have been collecting in-depth interviews with retail workers in these environments. So far I have completed twenty-seven interviews.
Retail work is the largest sector among the working class of America, and Walmart is the nation’s largest employer. Therefore, devoting attention to the politics of workers within this field is essential to understanding today’s working class. This paper seeks to bring to light the political perspective and agency of retail workers by focusing on their widespread resistance practices (e.g. stealing and quitting), as opposed to more traditionally recognized political actions (e.g. joining labor unions). Many workers care little for their retail jobs, or for the rules attached to them. The political stance of workers who briefly take what they can from a retail job, treat its authority with skepticism, and then depart as soon as they are able to, presents a new figure of political agency that is critical to understanding the reality of today’s precarious capitalist economy. Since retail workers’ perspectives are often marginalized or ignored in considerations of contemporary U.S. politics, they can make an important contribution towards this conference’s focus on pluralism.
In all of these workers’ accounts, a common trajectory emerges: it begins with a constrained economic setting, then takes a reluctant turn towards retail employment, and is followed by feelings of detachment and stasis setting in. In many cases employees become gradually more involved in acts of theft and/or time-wasting practices, and in almost every case there is an exit from the job. To develop and contextualize these accounts, the paper first explores the significance of the post-industrial environment : the geographic, cultural, and above-all economic restraints that lead individuals to consider retail work in the first place. Next, we listen to the words of workers themselves as they explain their feelings of apathy and alienation about these jobs. Furnished with these accounts, the resistant and antagonistic meaning behind retail workers’ everyday actions – from foot-dragging to absenteeism to theft – can be properly understood as political. Finally, we can understand the exit from retail labor, whether in the form of voluntary quitting or involuntary firing, as a politically consonant end to this trajectory.
This project draws on literature which has engaged with workers in these environments and communities in similar situations. There is a variety of literature that considers everyday worker practices and resistance, both in terms of contemporary ethnographic study and in terms of history. Adam Reich and Peter Bearman’s recent study of Walmart workers, Working for Respect, is an important starting point of comparison for this study. The major work on the history of Walmart, Nelson Lichtenstein’s The Retail Revolution, supplies similarly important background. The sub-field of Sociology around ‘organizational misbehavior’ also examines many minor forms of workplace resistance, especially in the works of Roland Paulsen, Jan Karlsson, and Kristin Carls. The ethnographic tradition of studying ‘infrapolitics’ and resistance, that extends at least from James Scott through Robin Kelly and Lorraine Bayard de Volo, gets even closer to these practices and their meanings. Ethnographic literature that has focused on other rural post-industrial communities in recent years is also significant, including authors Arlie Hochschild, Justin Gest, and J.D. Vance. Within the field of history, the sub-discipline of New Labor Studies has studied similar phenomena among workers extending back to early capitalism, especially in the works of E.P. Thompson and Peter Linebaugh. More recent theorizations by anarchist writers will also help to contextualize the resistance practices in question, as in the works of The Invisible Committee and CrimeThinc. Up-to-date analysis of the climate crisis, from Roy Scranton and Rupert Read among others, is also an important reference point.
Combining ethnographic immersion, thorough worker interviews, and academic theorization, my project aims to arrive at a new understanding of the role of retail labor in individual worker’s lives and in society more broadly. Beginning to focus more on the perspective of workers like these helps to broaden our pluralist perspective of contemporary America.