Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper introduces a new organizational framework for thinking about citizenship. Who qualifies, with full status, as an American citizen? And how has this changed over time? Like all modern nation-states, the United States erects and maintains a host of laws and geographic boundaries to demarcate citizens from noncitizens. When examining citizenship (as civic membership), the literature in political science tends to focus almost exclusively on the ways in which immigration law structures citizenship over time by privileging certain visions of nationhood and national identity. The broad set of laws regulating immigration and naturalization is typically termed the ‘immigration regime,’ but this paper argues this is only half the story. In a similar manner to immigration, governments such as the United States also pass laws and public policies regulating the birth of citizens from one generation to the next. I introduce the concept of a ‘civic lineage regime’ to describe these state-building policies for internal population control, which function as the domestic counterpart (or flipside) to the immigration regime when it comes to structuring the American polity from one generation to the next. By targeting the actual reproduction of citizens across time—via laws shaping fertility, intimacy, sexuality, family, marriage, and birth—these state-building policies define and redefine the meaning and scope of U.S. citizenship in far-reaching ways.
To bring visibility to this deeply constitutive yet largely unexamined dimension of American political development, this paper shines a light on two different civic lineage regimes, focusing on the noteworthy transition from 1) a Victorian ideal of citizenship during the Gilded Age to 2) a distinct Eugenic ideal during the Progressive Era. In order to highlight the ideals of civic reproduction that the U.S. government systematically institutionalized in each period, I engage in an analysis of state and federal civic lineage policies and the national court cases upholding them. In this manner. the paper traces the political development of one regime to the next, framing each in juxtaposition to their respective immigration regimes. As my analysis of these two key examples indicate, such state-building policies involving the regulation of reproduction and birth, have the ability to define and redefine the meaning and scope of U.S. citizenship across time by shaping the future “face” of the American polity. In both the realms of immigration and civic lineage, the state makes legal distinctions between who can and cannot become a member of its citizenry by coercively privileging (frequently inegalitarian) visions of American identity over others. This often entrenches hierarchies of citizenship based on factors such as race, gender, ethnicity, class, disability, religion, and sexuality.